Skip to content

Head to head

Babylon Berlin vs Peaky Blinders

Babylon Berlin takes it by 0.7, 8.8 against 8.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Babylon Berlin
Babylon Berlin

2017 · Excellent

  • Liv Lisa Fries makes Charlotte Ritter the show's engine, not Rath's sidekick
  • The Moka Efti scenes stage Weimar nightlife at a scale German television rarely tried
  • Conspiracies multiply until the central case can vanish for whole episodes
Cover of Peaky Blinders
Peaky Blinders

2013 · Excellent

  • Cillian Murphy's Tommy Shelby is a mesmerising, haunted antihero
  • Helen McCrory's Aunt Polly is formidable, funny and deeply human
  • Later seasons pile on grandiose plots at the cost of coherence

Where the gap is

Craft
9.68.9
Story
8.37.6
Characters
8.98.5
Performances
9.29.1

At a glance

FactBabylon BerlinPeaky Blinders
Released13 October 201712 September 2013
Created byTom Tykwer, Achim von BorriesSteven Knight
StarringVolker Bruch, Liv Lisa Fries, Peter KurthCillian Murphy, Sam Neill, Helen McCrory
NetworkSky 1 (seasons 1–4), ARD (season 5)BBC One
Seasons56
Episodes4836
GenreDrama · Thriller · CrimeDrama · Crime

The two verdicts

Babylon Berlin

Babylon Berlin: a crime story that keeps glancing at the clock on the Weimar Republic

Babylon Berlin is a crime series that uses its cases as a way of measuring a country's temperature, and it takes that reading with more money, music and visual nerve than any German drama before it. Charlotte Ritter gives it a heart, the Moka Efti gives it a pulse, and the decision to stop at 1933 gives the whole run a direction. The score stops short of the top tier because the storytelling too often confuses scale with depth: conspiracies stack on conspiracies, the central mystery goes missing for long stretches, and Rath's suffering becomes a refrain rather than a revelation. Those are the costs of ambition, and for a viewer willing to commit to the first sixteen episodes, they are worth paying.

Read the full review →

Peaky Blinders

Peaky Blinders: swaggering gangster mythmaking with Cillian Murphy at its icy centre

Peaky Blinders earns an 8.1 for Cillian Murphy's commanding performance, an unforgettable style and a vivid portrait of post-war Britain. Its overblown later plots, underused supporting characters and repetitive visual tics hold it back, but it remains a hugely enjoyable and influential crime saga.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.