Peaky Blinders · 2013
Peaky Blinders: swaggering gangster mythmaking with Cillian Murphy at its icy centre
Our review of Peaky Blinders, Steven Knight's BBC gangster saga: stylish, magnetic and superbly cast, though its later seasons grow overblown.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Peaky Blinders turned a little-known chapter of Birmingham's criminal history into a global cult phenomenon. With its razor-lined caps, sharp tailoring, brooding hero and thunderous rock soundtrack, Steven Knight's saga created a look and mood so distinctive that it influenced fashion as well as television. At its core is Cillian Murphy's performance as Tommy Shelby, one of the great antiheroes of British drama.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #58
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2013
- Released
- 6
- Seasons
The series is at its best when it combines swagger with melancholy. As it progresses, however, its ambitions grow larger than its storytelling, and the later seasons can feel more like an extended myth than a coherent drama.
Cillian Murphy gives a performance of remarkable control, conveying a torrent of pain, calculation and longing through piercing stillness.
Story
The first season is tight and atmospheric. Tommy, returned from the trenches with shattered nerves and a ruthless mind, schemes to expand the family's betting operation while a Belfast police inspector, played by Sam Neill, arrives to clean up the city. The early seasons move the Shelbys from local racecourses to London, pitting them against rival gangs, and the storytelling blends gangster thrills with an unusual sensitivity to working-class life, trauma and family loyalty.
As the seasons pass, the stakes rise dramatically. Tommy's ventures extend into international business, and later into Parliament, where he becomes entangled with the rise of British fascism. These plots are ambitious and occasionally powerful, but they rely on increasingly implausible leaps and elaborate schemes. The death of Helen McCrory before the final season inevitably affected its storytelling, and the concluding episodes, while striking, feel less focused than the show's best years.

Characters and performances
Cillian Murphy gives a performance of remarkable control, conveying a torrent of pain, calculation and longing through piercing stillness. Helen McCrory is magnificent as Polly, the family's matriarch, whose toughness and vulnerability make her one of the show's most beloved characters. Paul Anderson's volatile Arthur is both frightening and pitiable, and his struggle with the effects of war is treated with compassion.
The guest villains are a highlight. Tom Hardy's eccentric Alfie Solomons steals every scene he appears in, and Adrien Brody and Sam Claflin bring menace to later seasons. However, Ada and several other women are frequently sidelined, and some family members are defined by one trait.
Craft
The show's style is its signature. Directors use slow-motion walks, smoke-filled streets, sparks from foundries and saturated colours to turn Birmingham into an almost mythic landscape. The soundtrack, led by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds' Red Right Hand and featuring artists from PJ Harvey to Arctic Monkeys, lends a modern energy. Costume and production design are excellent. The stylistic flourishes can become repetitive, with the same slow-motion confrontations recurring across seasons.
Who it is for
Peaky Blinders is ideal for fans of gangster stories, period dramas with attitude and charismatic antiheroes. It features strong language, violence and drug use. Viewers who value tight plotting and realism may find the later seasons excessive.
What works
- Cillian Murphy's Tommy Shelby is a mesmerising, haunted antihero
- Helen McCrory's Aunt Polly is formidable, funny and deeply human
- Anachronistic rock soundtrack and slow-motion style are iconic
- Takes the lasting psychological damage of war seriously
What doesn’t
- Later seasons pile on grandiose plots at the cost of coherence
- Many female and supporting characters are underused
- The style can become repetitive and self-conscious
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.98.9
- Story
- 7.68.5
- Characters
- 8.58.7
- Performances
- 9.19.1
Fargo edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Peaky Blinders earns an 8.1 for Cillian Murphy's commanding performance, an unforgettable style and a vivid portrait of post-war Britain. Its overblown later plots, underused supporting characters and repetitive visual tics hold it back, but it remains a hugely enjoyable and influential crime saga.





