Fargo · 2014
Fargo: an anthology that honours the Coens by refusing to copy them
Our review of Fargo, Noah Hawley's FX crime anthology: darkly funny Midwestern tales with superb casts, though not every season hits as hard.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Turning a beloved film into a television series is usually a recipe for dilution. Noah Hawley's Fargo avoided that fate by treating the Coen brothers' film not as a story to be extended but as a sensibility to be explored: a world where polite, snowbound communities conceal greed and savagery, and where goodness is often quiet, dogged and unglamorous. The result is one of the most consistently rewarding anthologies of its era.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #35
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2014
- Released
- 5
- Seasons
Consistently, but not uniformly. Across five seasons the series produces a couple of masterpieces, some very good television and one notable misstep.
The second season's ensemble is outstanding, with Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons, Jean Smart, Patrick Wilson and Bokeem Woodbine all at their best.
Story
The first season, set in Minnesota in 2006, follows a meek insurance salesman whose life is upended by a chance meeting with a drifter who delights in chaos. It is a clever reworking of the film's themes, full of dark comedy and escalating violence. The second season, a prequel set in 1979 amid a war between a crime family and a Kansas City syndicate, is widely considered the series' high point, a sprawling, confident story that mixes political paranoia, family tragedy and one of the most extraordinary set pieces in modern television.
The third season, built around feuding twin brothers and a sinister corporate interloper, is sharp about the dawning era of misinformation, if slightly less focused. The fourth, set in 1950 Kansas City and centred on rival crime families, has ambition and a strong theme of assimilation but too many characters and too little propulsion. The fifth, a story of a housewife with a hidden past and a sheriff who believes he is the law, returned the series to form with a timely, bitterly funny look at debt, power and violence.

Characters and performances
Fargo's casting is superb. Billy Bob Thornton's Malvo, a smiling agent of disorder, and Martin Freeman's increasingly desperate salesman set a high standard, and Allison Tolman's diligent deputy is the kind of quietly heroic figure the series excels at. The second season's ensemble is outstanding, with Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons, Jean Smart, Patrick Wilson and Bokeem Woodbine all at their best. Carrie Coon anchors the third season beautifully, and Juno Temple and Jon Hamm make the fifth crackle.
Craft
The series is visually distinctive, with wide, snowy compositions, split-screen sequences in the second season and a wry eye for the absurd details of small-town life. Jeff Russo's scores move between mournful and propulsive. Hawley's taste for strange interludes, from unexplained phenomena to animated segments, can be delightful, but it occasionally distracts from the grounded moral drama that gives the show its weight.
Who it is for
Fans of the Coen brothers' work, crime fiction and dark comedy will find Fargo richly rewarding. Because each season stands alone, viewers can start anywhere, although the first two seasons remain the best introduction. The violence is sudden and often brutal.
What works
- The second season is one of the finest seasons of crime television
- Billy Bob Thornton's Lorne Malvo is a genuinely unnerving villain
- Captures the Coens' blend of absurdity, violence and Midwestern decency
- Every season assembles a remarkable ensemble cast
What doesn’t
- The fourth season is overstuffed and struggles to find momentum
- Surreal flourishes sometimes feel like quirk for its own sake
- Recurring archetypes grow familiar across later seasons
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.99.2
- Story
- 8.58.3
- Characters
- 8.78.5
- Performances
- 9.19.0
Fargo edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Fargo earns an 8.6 for its exceptional casts, a second season that ranks among television's best and a tone that respects its cinematic source while forging its own identity. The overcrowded fourth season, occasionally self-indulgent quirks and some repetition across instalments keep it below the very top tier, but as a whole it is a model of how to adapt a film for television.





