Mr. Robot · 2015
Mr. Robot: a paranoid, formally daring thriller for the surveillance age
Our review of Mr. Robot, Sam Esmail's USA Network thriller: Rami Malek leads a bold, unsettling hacker drama that reinvents itself as it goes.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Mr. Robot looked, on paper, like a straightforward techno-thriller: a young hacker, a secret society and a plot against a sinister corporation. In practice, it became one of the most formally adventurous dramas of the 2010s, a series that used unreliable narration, audacious visual style and a deep understanding of technology to explore loneliness, mental illness and the anger of a generation that feels powerless against corporate systems.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #40
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
It is not always easy company. The show can be oblique, and its second season in particular tested many viewers' patience. But over four seasons it tells a complete, deliberate story with a conclusion that recasts its journey in a moving light.
Robot suits viewers who enjoy complex psychological dramas, unreliable narrators and stories about technology and power.
Story
The first season is a gripping thriller. Elliot, who narrates to an imagined audience, is drawn into fsociety's plan to erase consumer debt by attacking E Corp, and the season builds to a climax that shakes the world of the show. Its interest in debt, surveillance and online radicalism felt remarkably timely, and its depiction of hacking, with realistic tools and techniques, won praise from people in the security field.
The second season deliberately slows down, spending much of its time inside Elliot's fragile mind, and while it has striking moments, its pacing and obfuscation frustrated many. The third season is tighter and more urgent, including an episode designed to look like a single continuous take through an office in chaos. The fourth season, built around a series of heists and confrontations, is widely regarded as a return to peak form, with a highly praised episode structured in five acts like an intense, claustrophobic stage play.

Characters and performances
Rami Malek's performance is extraordinary. With wide, haunted eyes and a flat, cautious delivery, he makes Elliot both alienating and heartbreakingly vulnerable. Christian Slater brings wild energy to the anarchist who recruits him. Carly Chaikin gives Darlene, Elliot's sister and fellow hacker, a spiky wit that deepens over time. Portia Doubleday traces Angela's shift from a naive friend to a figure of unsettling ambition, and Martin Wallström's Tyrell Wellick is a fascinating, unhinged corporate climber. BD Wong's enigmatic Whiterose is a memorable antagonist.
Some characters, particularly in the second and third seasons, drift through storylines that feel disconnected from the core plot.
Craft
Mr. Robot's visual style is unmistakable. Characters are frequently framed at the edge or bottom of the screen, surrounded by negative space, reflecting their isolation. Esmail directed every episode from the second season onwards, giving the series a singular vision. Mac Quayle's pulsing electronic score adds to the tension. The show's willingness to experiment, with sitcom pastiches, silent episodes and long takes, keeps it surprising, though not every experiment works equally well.
Who it is for
Mr. Robot suits viewers who enjoy complex psychological dramas, unreliable narrators and stories about technology and power. It depicts depression, drug addiction and violence. Those who want brisk, linear plotting will find the second season especially challenging.
What works
- Rami Malek makes Elliot's isolation and paranoia deeply affecting
- Hacking is depicted with unusual care for technical plausibility
- Sam Esmail's off-centre framing and bold experiments are striking
- The final season is a powerful, emotionally satisfying conclusion
What doesn’t
- The second season is slow and deliberately confusing
- Some supporting storylines lose momentum in the middle years
- Its fondness for reveals can feel like a puzzle rather than drama
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.28.9
- Story
- 8.38.5
- Characters
- 8.58.7
- Performances
- 9.09.1
Fargo edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Mr. Robot earns an 8.5 for Rami Malek's superb performance, Sam Esmail's daring direction and a story that grows into a moving examination of trauma and connection. Its sluggish second season, uneven supporting storylines and occasional over-reliance on reveals keep it from the highest tier, but it remains one of the most original dramas of its decade.





