Skip to content

Head to head

Fargo vs Peaky Blinders

Fargo takes it by 0.5, 8.6 against 8.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Fargo
Fargo

2014 · Excellent

  • The second season is one of the finest seasons of crime television
  • Billy Bob Thornton's Lorne Malvo is a genuinely unnerving villain
  • The fourth season is overstuffed and struggles to find momentum
Cover of Peaky Blinders
Peaky Blinders

2013 · Excellent

  • Cillian Murphy's Tommy Shelby is a mesmerising, haunted antihero
  • Helen McCrory's Aunt Polly is formidable, funny and deeply human
  • Later seasons pile on grandiose plots at the cost of coherence

Where the gap is

Craft
8.98.9
Story
8.57.6
Characters
8.78.5
Performances
9.19.1

At a glance

FactFargoPeaky Blinders
Released15 April 201412 September 2013
Created byNoah HawleySteven Knight
StarringBilly Bob Thornton, Allison Tolman, Colin HanksCillian Murphy, Sam Neill, Helen McCrory
NetworkFXBBC One
Seasons56
Episodes5136
GenreDrama · Crime · SuspenseDrama · Crime

The two verdicts

Fargo

Fargo: an anthology that honours the Coens by refusing to copy them

Fargo earns an 8.6 for its exceptional casts, a second season that ranks among television's best and a tone that respects its cinematic source while forging its own identity. The overcrowded fourth season, occasionally self-indulgent quirks and some repetition across instalments keep it below the very top tier, but as a whole it is a model of how to adapt a film for television.

Read the full review →

Peaky Blinders

Peaky Blinders: swaggering gangster mythmaking with Cillian Murphy at its icy centre

Peaky Blinders earns an 8.1 for Cillian Murphy's commanding performance, an unforgettable style and a vivid portrait of post-war Britain. Its overblown later plots, underused supporting characters and repetitive visual tics hold it back, but it remains a hugely enjoyable and influential crime saga.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.