Skip to content

Head to head

Band of Brothers vs Mad Men

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Band of Brothers
Band of Brothers

2001 · Essential

  • Ten episodes that each shift point of view, so the company is the protagonist
  • Veterans' interviews open each hour and keep the drama answerable to fact
  • A cast this large blurs together in helmets, especially in the early episodes
Cover of Mad Men
Mad Men

2007 · Essential

  • Jon Hamm's Don Draper is one of television's most complex creations
  • Peggy Olson's rise is a rich, decade-long portrait of ambition
  • Its slow, elliptical style can feel opaque or uneventful

Where the gap is

Craft
9.79.6
Story
9.29.1
Characters
9.09.7
Performances
9.39.5

At a glance

FactBand of BrothersMad Men
Released9 September 200119 July 2007
Created byTom Hanks, Erik JendresenMatthew Weiner
StarringDamian Lewis, Ron Livingston, Donnie WahlbergJon Hamm, Elisabeth Moss, Vincent Kartheiser
NetworkHBOAMC
Seasons1 (limited series)7
Episodes1092
GenreDrama · History · WarDrama

The two verdicts

Band of Brothers

Band of Brothers: the war series that trusts a company of men over a single hero

Band of Brothers earns its place near the top of the scale because it solved a problem war films rarely solve: how to make a reader care about a hundred men rather than one. It does it through structure, rotating the point of view episode by episode, and through patience, letting faces and names accumulate until the winter episodes land with real weight. The craft is exceptional and has barely dated. The score stops short of the very top for the reasons a first-time viewer will feel: a cast too large to follow in the early hours, a soft patch in the middle, and a view of the war that rarely looks beyond the American line. Those are real limits, and they are small against what the series achieves.

Read the full review →

Mad Men

Mad Men: a patient, piercing portrait of the American dream and its sales pitch

Mad Men scores 9.4 for extraordinary performances, writing of rare subtlety and a period recreation that serves profound themes of identity and reinvention. Its elliptical pacing and occasionally diffuse later seasons keep it a step below the very greatest landmarks, but it remains one of the richest dramas ever made for television.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.