Skip to content

Head to head

Barry vs Beef

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Barry
Barry

2018 · Excellent

  • Bill Hader's direction grows startlingly confident and inventive
  • Henry Winkler and Anthony Carrigan give unforgettable performances
  • The final season's bleakness squeezes out much of the humour
Cover of Beef
Beef

2023 · Excellent

  • Steven Yeun and Ali Wong give ferocious, vulnerable lead performances
  • Blends slapstick escalation with a serious look at depression and anger
  • Escalating plot contrivances strain plausibility in the later episodes

Where the gap is

Craft
9.28.4
Story
8.58.6
Characters
8.98.9
Performances
9.39.3

At a glance

FactBarryBeef
Released25 March 20186 April 2023
Created byBill Hader, Alec BergLee Sung Jin
StarringBill Hader, Stephen Root, Sarah GoldbergSteven Yeun, Ali Wong, Young Mazino
NetworkHBONetflix
Seasons41
Episodes3210
GenreDrama · Comedy · CrimeDrama · Comedy

The two verdicts

Barry

Barry: a hitman comedy that turned, brilliantly, into a study of guilt

Barry earns an 8.7 for outstanding performances, directing that grows more inventive with every season, and the seriousness with which it treats its central moral question. The final season's relentless gloom and a few rushed turns keep it from the very top rank, but few comedies have ever evolved so fearlessly into something so much deeper.

Read the full review →

Beef

Beef: a road-rage feud escalates into one of the sharpest dramas of its year

Beef is a bold, funny and deeply felt limited series with two exceptional lead performances and a thematic richness that lingers. Its escalating contrivances and occasionally thin supporting characters keep it from perfection. An 8.7 reflects a drama that turned a trivial grudge into a resonant portrait of modern anger and connection.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.