Skip to content

Head to head

Bicycle Thieves vs Roma

Bicycle Thieves takes it by 0.8, 9.5 against 8.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Bicycle Thieves
Bicycle Thieves

1948 · Masterpiece

  • A plot no bigger than one bicycle, which lets every scene carry the whole economy
  • Enzo Staiola's Bruno watches his father, and the film lets the audience watch him do it
  • Alessandro Cicognini's score pushes for tears the images have already earned
Cover of Roma
Roma

2018 · Excellent

  • Black-and-white photography of astonishing depth, detail and control
  • Yalitza Aparicio's natural, unforced presence carries the film with quiet force
  • Very slow, observational pace demands real patience from viewers

Where the gap is

Craft
9.09.7
Story
9.38.1
Direction
9.89.4
Performances
9.68.9

At a glance

FactBicycle ThievesRoma
Released24 November 194821 November 2018
DirectorVittorio De SicaAlfonso Cuaron
StarringLamberto Maggiorani, Enzo Staiola, Lianella CarellYalitza Aparicio, Marina de Tavira, Jorge Antonio Guerrero
Runtime89 minutes135 minutes
StudioProduzioni De SicaParticipant, Esperanto Filmoj
GenreDrama · NeorealismDrama

The two verdicts

Bicycle Thieves

Bicycle Thieves: a small theft that still carries the weight of a whole city

*Bicycle Thieves* earns its reputation the hard way, by doing something simple without a false step. One stolen bicycle opens on to a whole society, and the film never raises its voice to make the point; it trusts a pawnshop shelf, a wet market and a boy watching his father to do it. The performances by people who had never acted are still among the most convincing in cinema, and De Sica's direction has the patience of someone who knew exactly what he was looking at. The score is a period compromise and the post-dubbed dialogue occasionally shows, which keeps it a fraction below perfect. Neither touches what matters. More than seventy-five years on, it remains the first film to show anyone who asks where realist cinema begins, and one of the few landmarks that still plays as a story rather than a lesson.

Read the full review →

Roma

Roma: Alfonso Cuaron's intimate memory piece rendered on an epic canvas

Roma is a work of breathtaking craft and deep feeling, one of the most beautifully made films of its decade. Its pacing is deliberately austere, and its distance from Cleo's interior life keeps it from being as emotionally complete as it is visually magnificent. For patient viewers, though, it offers moments of rare power and an immersive portrait of a time and place.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.