Skip to content

Head to head

Black Mirror vs The Handmaid's Tale

Black Mirror takes it by 1.0, 8.4 against 7.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Black Mirror
Black Mirror

2011 · Excellent

  • San Junipero and Be Right Back are among television's finest single hours
  • Many early episodes anticipated real social and political shifts
  • Later seasons are noticeably less consistent than the early ones
Cover of The Handmaid's Tale
  • Elisabeth Moss gives a ferocious, deeply physical central performance
  • Ann Dowd's Aunt Lydia is a chillingly plausible true believer
  • Later seasons repeat cycles of suffering with diminishing returns

Where the gap is

Craft
8.48.7
Story
8.66.8
Characters
7.97.6
Performances
8.59.1

At a glance

FactBlack MirrorThe Handmaid's Tale
Released4 December 201126 April 2017
Created byCharlie BrookerBruce Miller
StarringDaniel Lapaine, Hannah John-Kamen, Michaela CoelElisabeth Moss, Joseph Fiennes, Yvonne Strahovski
NetworkNetflixHulu
Seasons65
Episodes2756
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · SuspenseSci-Fi · Drama · Suspense

The two verdicts

Black Mirror

Black Mirror: brilliant cautionary tales, unevenly spread across the years

Black Mirror scores 8.4 because its strongest episodes are among the most influential and memorable of the century, and its sharpest satire has aged uncomfortably well. The inconsistency of later seasons, a tendency to rely on the sting in the tail and a pessimism that can feel formulaic stop it from scoring higher. As a collection, it remains essential; as a whole, it is best enjoyed selectively.

Read the full review →

The Handmaid's Tale

The Handmaid's Tale: a harrowing first season, then a dystopia that would not end

The Handmaid's Tale began as one of the most powerful dramas of its decade, anchored by a towering central performance and impeccable craft. Its extended run, however, diluted that impact with repetitive storytelling and diminishing credibility. A 7.4 honours its outstanding opening and cast while accounting for the long decline that followed.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.