The Handmaid's Tale · 2017
The Handmaid's Tale: a harrowing first season, then a dystopia that would not end
The Handmaid's Tale review: Hulu's adaptation of Margaret Atwood's novel is a powerful, superbly acted dystopia whose later seasons stretch its story thin.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Few dramas have arrived with the cultural urgency of The Handmaid's Tale. Its first season, adapting Margaret Atwood's novel with fidelity and visual invention, became a touchstone for debates about reproductive rights and authoritarianism, and its red cloaks and white bonnets turned into an internationally recognised protest symbol. As a single season of television, it is devastating and brilliant.
- 7.4
- Editorial score
- #85
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2017
- Released
- 5
- Seasons
The problem is what followed. Having covered the novel's story, the series continued for years, and while it retained exceptional performances and moments of great power, its storytelling increasingly circled the same torments without deepening them.
The Handmaid's Tale is essential viewing in its first season for anyone interested in dystopian fiction or feminist storytelling.
Story
The first season introduces Gilead through June's eyes, cutting between her present life as a handmaid and flashbacks to the ordinary world that crumbled into dictatorship. The gradual revelation of how quickly rights were stripped away is chilling precisely because it feels plausible, and the ceremonies, punishments and rules of the regime are depicted with unflinching specificity.
Beyond the novel, the later seasons expand to explore resistance movements, life in exile in Canada, and the inner workings of Gilead's leadership. Some of these ideas are rich, but the series often repeats a pattern of hope, brutal setback and defiant close-up. June's survival through increasingly dangerous situations stretches plausibility, and the relentless cruelty begins to feel less like critique and more like endurance for its own sake.

Characters and performances
Elisabeth Moss's performance is extraordinary. She conveys June's rage, terror and cunning often without words, her face shifting between compliance and fury in a single shot. Yvonne Strahovski's Serena Joy, a woman who helped build the regime that now confines her, is one of the most complex figures in the series, and the tangled relationship between the two women drives much of its best drama.
Ann Dowd's Aunt Lydia, whose cruelty is sincerely maternal, is terrifying, while Alexis Bledel's Emily and Madeline Brewer's Janine offer heartbreaking portraits of trauma. Bradley Whitford brings sly ambiguity to Commander Lawrence in later seasons. Joseph Fiennes is effectively repellent as Fred, a man who sees himself as decent.
Craft
The visual design is remarkable. Reed Morano's direction of the opening episodes established a striking palette, with symmetrical compositions, harsh contrasts and the vivid red of the handmaids' clothing against grey and teal surroundings. The use of contemporary pop songs over closing scenes provides a jarring contrast. Over time, however, the show's stylistic flourishes, particularly lingering slow motion and extreme close-ups of Moss, become mannered and repetitive.
Who it is for
The Handmaid's Tale is essential viewing in its first season for anyone interested in dystopian fiction or feminist storytelling. Its later seasons will reward invested viewers, but those who find sustained depictions of abuse and violence distressing should approach with care.
What works
- Elisabeth Moss gives a ferocious, deeply physical central performance
- Ann Dowd's Aunt Lydia is a chillingly plausible true believer
- The first season's direction makes Gilead's rituals terrifyingly real
- Yvonne Strahovski turns Serena Joy into a complex, tragic figure
What doesn’t
- Later seasons repeat cycles of suffering with diminishing returns
- June's repeated narrow escapes stretch credibility past breaking point
- Stylised slow motion and extreme close-ups become a wearying tic
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.78.4
- Story
- 6.88.6
- Characters
- 7.67.9
- Performances
- 9.18.5
Black Mirror edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
The Handmaid's Tale began as one of the most powerful dramas of its decade, anchored by a towering central performance and impeccable craft. Its extended run, however, diluted that impact with repetitive storytelling and diminishing credibility. A 7.4 honours its outstanding opening and cast while accounting for the long decline that followed.





