Skip to content

Head to head

Black Science vs Y: The Last Man

Y: The Last Man takes it by 1.4, 8.6 against 7.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Black Science
Black Science

2013 · Good

  • Matteo Scalera's kinetic, scratchy art makes every alien world feel dangerous
  • Inventive dimensional set pieces, from frog-men wars to techno-shamanic America
  • Grant McKay's self-pity and narration become exhausting over 43 issues
Cover of Y: The Last Man
Y: The Last Man

2002 · Excellent

  • A brilliant premise explored with wit, imagination and emotional depth
  • Yorick, 355 and Dr Mann form a compelling central trio
  • Some depictions of gender and women's groups are simplistic

Where the gap is

Art
8.98.2
Story
6.88.7
Pacing
6.98.1
Characters
6.68.9

At a glance

FactBlack ScienceY: The Last Man
Released27 November 20131 September 2002
WriterRick RemenderBrian K. Vaughan
PublisherImage ComicsDC Comics
Issues4360
GenreAdventure · Sci-Fi · DramaAdventure · Sci-Fi · Drama
Artist—Pia Guerra

The two verdicts

Black Science

Black Science is a breathless multiverse ride dragged down by its miserable hero

Black Science has thrilling art, a brilliant concept and a handful of unforgettable worlds. It is undercut by a narrator who is hard to spend time with, a cast that rarely gets room to grow and a long middle that spins its wheels. A 7.2 recognises a good, often exhilarating series whose emotional arc does not match its imagination.

Read the full review →

Y: The Last Man

Y: The Last Man turns a high-concept apocalypse into a warm, witty odyssey

Y: The Last Man is a gripping, funny and moving series that turns a provocative premise into a rich exploration of society and identity. Its dated gender politics, occasionally irritating protagonist and slower middle arcs hold it back from the very top. An 8.6 reflects an excellent, landmark series whose characters make it unforgettable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.