Skip to content

Head to head

Blankets vs Spider-Man: Blue

Blankets takes it by 0.9, 8.6 against 7.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Blankets
Blankets

2003 · Excellent

  • Brush drawing that turns snow, quilts and blank space into the book's real language
  • The brothers' shared childhood bed gives the whole memoir its emotional anchor
  • Raina is seen almost entirely through Craig's longing and stays partly out of focus
Cover of Spider-Man: Blue
Spider-Man: Blue

2002 · Good

  • Tim Sale's warm, retro art beautifully captures the 1960s Romita era
  • Gwen Stacy is given a depth and charm often missing from the originals
  • The villain encounters are thin and feel like filler

Where the gap is

Art
9.49.0
Story
8.36.9
Pacing
7.97.2
Characters
8.48.1

At a glance

FactBlanketsSpider-Man: Blue
Released23 July 20031 July 2002
WriterCraig ThompsonJeph Loeb
ArtistCraig Thompson—
PublisherTop Shelf Productions, Drawn & QuarterlyMarvel Comics
IssuesOne volume, an original graphic novel not serialised beforehand6
GenreRomance · Graphic Novel · Coming of ageRomance · Superhero

The two verdicts

Blankets

Blankets: a memoir of first love whose drawings say what its words cannot

*Blankets* is one of the books that showed what an American graphic novel about ordinary life could look like, and it still looks extraordinary. Thompson's drawing turns snow, sheets and silence into a vocabulary of feeling, and his account of a boy outgrowing the faith that formed him is fair to everyone involved, including the boy. The score stops short of the top tier for reasons the book itself makes visible: a middle stretch that lingers longer than its story needs, and a first love who remains more an image than a person. Those limits are real, and they are the limits of memory itself. For readers willing to move at its pace, it is a deeply rewarding book, and one that is easy to return to every few winters.

Read the full review →

Spider-Man: Blue

Spider-Man: Blue is a tender, lovely valentine that barely has a story to tell

Spider-Man: Blue is a beautifully drawn and affectionate tribute to Peter Parker's youth and to Gwen Stacy, with a sincerity that makes its best moments land. Thin plotting, perfunctory villains and a reliance on nostalgia keep it from being essential. A 7.7 reflects a good, heartfelt miniseries that is more mood piece than story.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.