Skip to content

Head to head

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild vs Shadow of the Colossus

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild takes it by 0.5, 9.7 against 9.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
  • Climb any surface and glide from any height: the world is truly open
  • Physics and chemistry systems invite endless experimentation
  • Weapons break constantly, discouraging players from using favourites
Cover of Shadow of the Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus

2005 · Essential

  • Every colossus is a level, a puzzle and a boss at once, and no two are solved alike
  • Agro, the horse, feels like a companion with a will rather than a vehicle
  • The PS2 original struggles badly with its frame rate during the larger fights

Where the gap is

Story
7.89.2
Gameplay
9.88.9
Longevity
9.68.3
Presentation
9.49.6

At a glance

FactThe Legend of Zelda: Breath of the WildShadow of the Colossus
Released3 March 201718 October 2005
DeveloperNintendo, Nintendo Entertainment Planning & DevelopmentTeam Ico
PublisherNintendoSony Interactive Entertainment
PlatformsNintendo Switch, Nintendo Wii UPlayStation 2, PlayStation 3
DirectorHidemaro FujibayashiFumito Ueda
EngineCustomProprietary
GenreAction · Adventure · Open worldAction · Adventure · Open world

The two verdicts

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Breath of the Wild tore up the open-world rulebook and rebuilt it around curiosity

Breath of the Wild earns a landmark score because it changed how an entire genre thinks about freedom, and because its moment-to-moment exploration remains exhilarating. Fragile weapons, thin dungeons and a sparse story are real flaws, yet they are small beside a game this confident, this influential and this consistently surprising.

Read the full review →

Shadow of the Colossus

Shadow of the Colossus: sixteen fights, one empty land, and a guilt that grows with every win

Shadow of the Colossus is a game built from very few parts, and every one of them is doing two jobs. The colossi are both levels and characters, the empty land is both a map and a mood, and the triumph of each kill is both a reward and an accusation. That density of purpose is why it still feels ahead of most of what followed. The score stops short of the very top because the original release asks real forbearance from its players: a frame rate that buckles under its own ambition, a camera that loses its subject, and climbing that can tip from desperate into merely clumsy. None of that dulls the central achievement. Few games have made a player feel so small, so determined and so uneasy about winning.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.