Skip to content
Game reviewEssential

Shadow of the Colossus · 2005

Shadow of the Colossus: sixteen fights, one empty land, and a guilt that grows with every win

Shadow of the Colossus review. Team Ico's 2005 PlayStation 2 game turns sixteen boss fights into climbs and makes every victory feel a little worse.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Action games usually ask you to feel powerful. Shadow of the Colossus asks you to notice what that power costs. Fumito Ueda's second game strips the form down to a horse, a sword, a bow and sixteen enormous creatures, and then makes each victory land with a little less certainty than the one before. Nothing in it is explained at length, and almost nothing needs to be.

9.2
Editorial score
#24
Of 116 games reviewed
2005
Released
9.6
Best at: Presentation

It arrived on the PlayStation 2 in October 2005, four years after Team Ico's debut, Ico, and it has outlived its hardware with ease. The ideas it introduced, a boss as a piece of geography, an open world kept empty on purpose, a companion who is an animal and behaves like one, still read as fresh because so few games have dared to repeat them. The original also runs poorly, controls stubbornly and asks for patience it does not always repay. Those faults are real, and they do not change the verdict much.

How it plays

The structure is as plain as any game has attempted. Wander stands in the Shrine of Worship, Dormin names the next colossus, and Wander raises his sword so that its reflected light points the way. Then comes the ride, sometimes short, sometimes across half the map, and then the creature itself. Everything turns on that encounter. There are no smaller enemies to farm, no shops and no skill tree: lizards and fruit raise health and stamina a little, and that is the whole economy.

Each colossus is a problem to read before it is a fight. The first, a bearded giant with a club, teaches the grammar: find a handhold in its fur, climb while a circular stamina gauge drains, reach the glowing sigil and drive the sword in while the creature bucks. Later colossi change the question entirely. One must be lured, one must be reached from the air, one lives in water. The solution is usually something about the arena rather than about Wander, and the satisfaction is the satisfaction of having understood a place.

The climbing is the part that has aged most. Holding R1 to grip and timing jumps against a body that sways and shakes is deliberately unwieldy, and the camera, which pulls back to frame the colossus rather than the player, can lose Wander at the worst moments. That friction has a purpose, since the fights are meant to feel desperate rather than slick, but there are moments where desperation tips over into simple struggle with the controls.

How it measures up

Difficulty
6/10
Puzzles more than reflexes; the controls add the rest
Exploration
7/10
A large, sparse map with few secrets, by design
Story clarity
4/10
Told in fragments and silences
Boss variety
9.5/10
No two colossi are solved the same way
Time to credits
11/20
Hours on a first run, against Time Attack and Hard mode
Shadow of the Colossus
Shadow of the ColossusSony Computer Entertainment, via PlayStation Blog (2011 PlayStation 3 remaster)

The forbidden land

The land between the fights divides players more than anything else in the game. It is enormous for a PlayStation 2 world and almost entirely empty: plains, cliffs, a forest, a lake, ruined temples with no one in them. Riding across it takes minutes at a time, and nothing attacks. Some players call that dead space. It is closer to the opposite. The emptiness is where the game does its thinking, the stretch in which a player has time to wonder what the last colossus was doing before Wander arrived.

Agro carries that stretch. The horse does not respond like a car. She drifts away from cliff edges on her own, slows when the terrain turns rough and occasionally ignores a command she considers unwise. In 2005 that animal stubbornness was unusual enough to annoy people; now it reads as one of the most convincing companions in the medium, and the bond it builds over hours of riding is the emotional engine of the whole game.

A boss fight that feels like a crime is a rare thing, and this game manages sixteen.

Watch
Shadow of the Colossus — trailer

Story without words

What is said in Shadow of the Colossus can be summarised in a few lines. Wander arrives, Dormin makes its offer, and a fallen colossus releases dark tendrils that strike Wander down before he wakes again at the shrine. The dialogue is in an invented language with subtitles, and there is little of it. The rest is carried by the player's own unease. The colossi rarely attack first. Several of them graze, or sleep, or simply walk. When one falls, the music does not celebrate.

That restraint is what makes the story land. The game never tells you that what Wander is doing is wrong; it shows you, quietly and repeatedly, and lets the player's growing reluctance do the rest. The premise asks a simple question about how far grief can push someone, and the structure makes the player answer it with their own hands, sixteen times. Nothing past the first fight needs spoiling for that to be clear, and nothing will be here.

  1. 2001

    Ico releases on PlayStation 2; work on a follow-up begins straight after

  2. 2002

    A concept video for a project codenamed Nico is completed

  3. 2005

    Shadow of the Colossus releases in North America on 18 October and in Japan on 27 October

  4. 2006

    The PAL release arrives in February, with four art cards in the box

  5. 2011

    Bluepoint Games remasters it with Ico for PlayStation 3

  6. 2018

    Bluepoint's full remake releases on PlayStation 4

Gallery · 3 imagesSony Computer Entertainment, via PlayStation Blog (2011 PlayStation 3 remaster)

Presentation

The art direction asks the PlayStation 2 to do more than it comfortably could. Bloom washes over the plains, the colours are drained towards grey and ochre, and the colossi are covered in fur and moss that sways as they move. Their scale is sold through the camera and through sound: the thud of a footstep arrives a beat after the foot lands. Wander himself is small, thin and visibly tired, and his animation, the way he dangles and slips and hauls himself up, does more to convey effort than any health bar could.

Kow Otani's score is the other half of the presentation. The ride between fights is mostly silent, wind and hooves, and the music arrives only when a colossus does. Once a hold is found and the climb begins, the orchestra swells into something heroic, and that heroic register is exactly what the game wants the player to question. The soundtrack, released in Japan as Roar of the Earth, is often discussed as one of the best of its console generation.

Which version to play

The question most new players face is not whether to play it but which version. The original is the work as it was made, flaws included, and it remains playable on the hardware it was designed for. The 2011 remaster keeps everything about the game except its performance problems, which makes it the closest thing to the intended experience. The 2018 remake by Bluepoint is the most comfortable, with modern controls and entirely new assets, though some players feel its sharper, more detailed look softens the original's haze.

Versions at a glance
VersionYearPlatformWorth knowing
Original2005PlayStation 2The work as made; the frame rate suffers in big fights
HD remaster2011PlayStation 3Same game and art, much smoother, paired with Ico
Remake2018PlayStation 4Rebuilt by Bluepoint with new assets and controls

Its nearest relative in the catalogue is a much later and much busier game. Both are built on a large world that refuses to fill itself with icons, and both trust the player to find the shape of it. The difference is that Nintendo's open world wants you to play in it, while Ueda's wants you to wonder why you are there.

Head to head

Story
9.27.8
Gameplay
8.99.8
Longevity
8.39.6
Presentation
9.69.4

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild edges it by 0.5. See them side by side

Players who come to it from Breath of the Wild will recognise the climbing and the silence; those who loved the wordless mood of Inside will recognise the way meaning is left for the player to assemble.

For you if

  • Anyone who wants a boss fight to feel like an event rather than a health bar
  • Players who enjoy quiet, unhurried worlds and stories told through images
  • Anyone curious about where many later action games found their ideas

Not for you if

  • Players who need constant combat or a stream of rewards between fights
  • Anyone with little patience for awkward cameras and deliberate controls
  • Those who want a story spelled out rather than left to interpretation

Anyone deciding whether the long rides and the silences will suit them can find out within the first colossus; the game does not change its mind after that.

What works

  • Every colossus is a level, a puzzle and a boss at once, and no two are solved alike
  • Agro, the horse, feels like a companion with a will rather than a vehicle
  • The empty land makes the long rides between fights part of the meaning
  • Kow Otani's score turns triumphant at the exact moment the game wants you to doubt

What doesn’t

  • The PS2 original struggles badly with its frame rate during the larger fights
  • The camera and the climbing controls fight the player as often as the colossi do
  • Little to do outside the sixteen battles, which some will read as thin
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Shadow of the Colossus is a game built from very few parts, and every one of them is doing two jobs. The colossi are both levels and characters, the empty land is both a map and a mood, and the triumph of each kill is both a reward and an accusation. That density of purpose is why it still feels ahead of most of what followed. The score stops short of the very top because the original release asks real forbearance from its players: a frame rate that buckles under its own ambition, a camera that loses its subject, and climbing that can tip from desperate into merely clumsy. None of that dulls the central achievement. Few games have made a player feel so small, so determined and so uneasy about winning.

Quick answers

Is Shadow of the Colossus worth playing?

Voxizer scores Shadow of the Colossus (2005) 9.2 out of 10 — essential. Shadow of the Colossus is a game built from very few parts, and every one of them is doing two jobs. The colossi are both levels and characters, the empty land is both a map and a mood, and the triumph of each kill is both a reward and an accusation.

Who will enjoy Shadow of the Colossus?

Anyone who wants a boss fight to feel like an event rather than a health bar. Players who enjoy quiet, unhurried worlds and stories told through images. Anyone curious about where many later action games found their ideas.

Who should skip Shadow of the Colossus?

Players who need constant combat or a stream of rewards between fights. Anyone with little patience for awkward cameras and deliberate controls. Those who want a story spelled out rather than left to interpretation.

What is Shadow of the Colossus like, in short?

Sixteen boss fights and nothing else, each one a climbable puzzle with its own logic. The vast, quiet land between fights is the point, not padding. A story told almost without words that makes the player complicit. The PS2 original stutters in big fights; the 2011 remaster or the 2018 remake are smoother ways in.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Shadow of the Colossus yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for games: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.