Skip to content

Head to head

Chainsaw Man vs Tokyo Ghoul

Chainsaw Man takes it by 1.5, 8.3 against 6.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Chainsaw Man
Chainsaw Man

2022 · Excellent

  • Film-like direction with naturalistic lighting and handheld-style camerawork
  • Denji's crude, simple desires make him a refreshingly honest protagonist
  • Muted, deliberate tone dulls some of the manga's manic comedy
Cover of Tokyo Ghoul
Tokyo Ghoul

2014 · Mixed

  • A compelling premise about identity, hunger and moral compromise
  • Kaneki's struggle to reconcile his two natures is initially gripping
  • Heavy compression rushes character arcs and important story beats

Where the gap is

Sound
8.68.3
Story
8.26.5
Animation
8.96.8
Characters
8.76.9

At a glance

FactChainsaw ManTokyo Ghoul
Released12 October 20224 July 2014
StudioMAPPAStudio Pierrot
Episodes1212
StatusAiringCompleted
GenreAction · Seinen · HorrorAction · Seinen · Horror
Director—Shuhei Morita

The two verdicts

Chainsaw Man

Chainsaw Man: a gorgeous, restrained take on a gloriously unhinged manga

Chainsaw Man's first season is a lavish, stylish adaptation with a memorable cast and exceptional craft. Its measured tone, patchy CG and mid-arc ending held it back from universal acclaim, and debate about its direction was loud among fans. Judged on its own terms, it is a very good season of television that sets up a great story, and an 8.3 reflects both its polish and its compromises.

Read the full review →

Tokyo Ghoul

Tokyo Ghoul: a striking dark fantasy that rushes through its best material

Tokyo Ghoul's score reflects a strong premise and an iconic soundtrack weighed down by rushed pacing, thin supporting characters and disruptive censorship. Its early episodes show what a great adaptation could have been, but as a whole it is a mixed, frustrating experience that works best as an introduction to Sui Ishida's far richer source material.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.