Skip to content
Anime reviewMixed

Tokyo Ghoul · 2014

Tokyo Ghoul: a striking dark fantasy that rushes through its best material

Tokyo Ghoul review: Studio Pierrot's 2014 adaptation of Sui Ishida's manga has a great premise and an iconic opening, but compression and censorship hurt it.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda3 min read

Mixed

Editorial score out of 10

Tokyo Ghoul has one of the most effective hooks in modern dark fantasy: a gentle bookworm becomes a monster that must eat people to survive, and is forced to decide what kind of person he can still be. Combined with a memorable opening theme and striking visual design, that premise made the anime a gateway series for many viewers.

6.8
Editorial score
#92
Of 93 anime reviewed
2014
Released
12
Episodes

The adaptation itself, however, is much weaker than its premise. It moves too quickly through its source, and its broadcast version is marred by censorship that obscures some of its most important moments.

Touka, the prickly café waitress who becomes Kaneki's reluctant mentor, gets some development, but many other ghouls and investigators receive only a few scenes.

Between two worlds

The opening episodes are the show's strongest. Kaneki's transformation is presented with genuine horror: his revulsion at ordinary food, his hunger, and his fear of what he might do to his best friend. The café Anteiku offers him refuge, and its manager and staff introduce a community of ghouls trying to live quietly and ethically in a hostile city.

The central question of who the real monsters are is compelling. Ghouls must kill or scavenge to survive, but the government investigators hunting them can be just as ruthless, and the series tries to present both sides with some sympathy. The investigator Amon, who begins as an antagonist, is one of its more interesting figures.

Tokyo Ghoul
Tokyo GhoulAniList & AniChart

Too much, too fast

The biggest problem is pacing. Twelve episodes attempt to cover a large portion of the manga, and the result is rushed. Arcs that should build slowly are compressed, and character development often happens between scenes rather than on screen. Kaneki's psychological shift in the final episodes, which should be the payoff of his entire arc, feels abrupt because the groundwork has been cut back.

Supporting characters suffer most. Touka, the prickly café waitress who becomes Kaneki's reluctant mentor, gets some development, but many other ghouls and investigators receive only a few scenes. Viewers who have read the manga often feel that much of its nuance is lost.

Later seasons diverged from the manga and were widely considered less successful, which makes this first season the most coherent part of the anime, but also emphasises how much further the story could have gone with more room.

Watch
Tokyo Ghoul — trailer

Look and sound

Studio Pierrot's production is uneven. Ghoul designs, especially the kagune, the predatory organs that emerge from their bodies as weapons, are visually striking, and some fights are dynamic. Other scenes look flat, with limited movement and inconsistent drawings. The broadcast version also applied heavy censorship, using dark shadows and blurs to hide gore, which weakens several key moments; home releases restore much of the missing detail.

Sound is the strongest element. The opening song, unravel by TK from Ling Tosite Sigure, is an explosive, anguished anthem that captures Kaneki's torment perfectly and remains one of the most recognisable anime themes of its era. Yutaka Yamada's score, full of eerie strings and choral cues, supports the dark atmosphere well.

Gallery · 3 imagesAniList & AniChart

Who it is for

Tokyo Ghoul will suit viewers who enjoy dark fantasy and horror, and it can be an entry point to its excellent manga. It contains graphic violence and a notorious torture sequence. Those who want the story in full are better served by the manga, and viewers should seek out uncensored releases where possible.

What works

  • A compelling premise about identity, hunger and moral compromise
  • Kaneki's struggle to reconcile his two natures is initially gripping
  • The opening theme unravel is one of the most iconic of its decade
  • Striking visual design for ghouls and their kagune weapons

What doesn’t

  • Heavy compression rushes character arcs and important story beats
  • Broadcast censorship obscures many key scenes with dark overlays
  • Many supporting characters have too little screen time to matter

Head to head

Sound
8.38.6
Story
6.58.2
Animation
6.88.9
Characters
6.98.7

Chainsaw Man edges it by 1.5. See them side by side

MixedHow we score

The verdict

Tokyo Ghoul's score reflects a strong premise and an iconic soundtrack weighed down by rushed pacing, thin supporting characters and disruptive censorship. Its early episodes show what a great adaptation could have been, but as a whole it is a mixed, frustrating experience that works best as an introduction to Sui Ishida's far richer source material.

Quick answers

Is Tokyo Ghoul worth watching?

Voxizer scores Tokyo Ghoul (2014) 6.8 out of 10 — mixed. Tokyo Ghoul's score reflects a strong premise and an iconic soundtrack weighed down by rushed pacing, thin supporting characters and disruptive censorship. Its early episodes show what a great adaptation could have been, but as a whole it is a mixed, frustrating experience that works best as an introduction to Sui Ishida's far richer source material.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Tokyo Ghoul yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for anime: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.