Skip to content

Head to head

Chinatown vs No Country for Old Men

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Chinatown
Chinatown

1974 · Essential

  • A plot where every clue is about water, land and money rather than a missing gun
  • Nicholson's Gittes is in nearly every scene, so the audience learns only what he learns
  • The middle hour is dense with deeds, maps and names; inattention is punished
Cover of No Country for Old Men
No Country for Old Men

2007 · Essential

  • Javier Bardem makes Anton Chigurh genuinely frightening without raising his voice
  • Near-absence of music turns every footstep and creaking door into suspense
  • The final stretch deliberately withholds the payoff many viewers expect

Where the gap is

Craft
9.39.6
Story
9.89.2
Direction
9.59.7
Performances
9.49.5

At a glance

FactChinatownNo Country for Old Men
Released20 June 19749 November 2007
DirectorRoman PolanskiEthan Coen, Joel Coen
StarringJack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway, John HustonTommy Lee Jones, Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin
Runtime130 minutes122 minutes
StudioLong Road Productions, Paramount PicturesParamount Vantage, Miramax
GenreThriller · Noir · CrimeDrama · Crime · Suspense

The two verdicts

Chinatown

Chinatown: a detective story where the crime is the city's plumbing

Chinatown earns its reputation through precision. Every scene carries information, every performance is pitched to the scale of the room, and the script's choice of subject, water rights in place of jewels or a dead partner, gives the genre a weight it rarely carries. It is held just short of the very top tier because its middle stretch asks a great deal of a modern viewer's patience, and because its density can leave a first-time audience a step behind rather than pleasurably so. Those are small costs. As a piece of storytelling about how power works in a modern city, very few films have matched it in the half-century since.

Read the full review →

No Country for Old Men

No Country for Old Men: the Coens turn a chase thriller into a quiet elegy

No Country for Old Men won Best Picture and has only grown in stature since, and it earns that standing through near-flawless execution rather than spectacle. Direction, cinematography and performances all operate at the highest level. The only reason it stops just short of the very top of the scale is that its deliberately elusive final movement can leave first-time viewers unsettled rather than moved, even if repeat viewings reveal its design.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.