Skip to content

Head to head

Chromakopia vs To Pimp a Butterfly

To Pimp a Butterfly takes it by 0.7, 9.4 against 8.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Chromakopia
Chromakopia

2024 · Excellent

  • Bonita Smith's spoken passages give fourteen scattered tracks one spine
  • Tyler produced every track himself, and no arrangement sits still for long
  • The sequencing lurches between party records and confessions
Cover of To Pimp a Butterfly
To Pimp a Butterfly

2015 · Essential

  • A rich blend of jazz, funk and soul played by a stellar band
  • Alright became an enduring anthem of protest and resilience
  • Nearly 80 minutes of dense material makes it demanding to revisit

Where the gap is

Cohesion
7.89.3
Production
9.29.4
Performance
8.99.6
Songwriting
8.89.7

At a glance

FactChromakopiaTo Pimp a Butterfly
Released28 October 202415 March 2015
ArtistTyler, the CreatorKendrick Lamar
LabelColumbia RecordsInterscope Records, Top Dawg Entertainment
Tracks1416
Length52:5478:51
GenreHip-hop · Jazz · SoulHip-hop · Jazz · Funk

The two verdicts

Chromakopia

Chromakopia: the messiest Tyler record, and the one with the most at stake

Chromakopia is the sound of an artist with total control of his tools choosing not to use it. The production is the richest of his career, the writing is the most exposed, and the record is held together by a voice that belongs to somebody who never asked to be on it. What keeps the score below the top tier is the sequencing: the turns between the party and the confession are abrupt often enough to break a first listen, and a couple of songs stop before their ideas do. That looseness is also why it lands harder than the albums either side of it. Tidier records will age more comfortably. Few will feel this close to someone thinking aloud.

Read the full review →

To Pimp a Butterfly

To Pimp a Butterfly: Kendrick Lamar's dense, jazz-soaked reckoning with America

To Pimp a Butterfly scores 9.4: an exceptional album, and one of the defining artistic statements of its era. Its songwriting, performances and musical ambition are almost unmatched in modern hip-hop, and its cultural impact has been profound. Its length and density keep it just short of the landmark tier for some listeners, but its achievement is undeniable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.