Skip to content

Head to head

Civil War vs Top Gun: Maverick

Top Gun: Maverick takes it by 0.7, 8.1 against 7.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Civil War
Civil War

2024 · Good

  • Harrowing, precisely staged scenes of violence and fear
  • Kirsten Dunst gives a weary, hollowed-out lead performance
  • Its refusal to explain the war's politics feels evasive
Cover of Top Gun: Maverick
Top Gun: Maverick

2022 · Excellent

  • Real in-cockpit aerial footage gives the flying scenes unmatched intensity
  • Tom Cruise brings charisma and a new, weary vulnerability to Maverick
  • The plot follows a familiar formula with few surprises

Where the gap is

Craft
8.39.4
Story
6.87.2
Direction
8.18.7
Performances
8.07.8

At a glance

FactCivil WarTop Gun: Maverick
Released12 April 202427 May 2022
DirectorAlex GarlandJoseph Kosinski
StarringKirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley HendersonTom Cruise, Val Kilmer, Jennifer Connelly
Runtime109 minutes131 minutes
StudioA24Skydance Media, TC Productions
GenreAction · Drama · WarAction · Drama

The two verdicts

Civil War

Civil War: a harrowing road movie about the people who photograph collapse

Civil War is gripping, well-acted and technically accomplished, with individual scenes that linger long after it ends. Its studied political vagueness and predictable character arcs, however, stop it from being the searching statement it gestures towards. As a harrowing, sometimes frustrating piece of speculative war cinema, it earns a 7.4.

Read the full review →

Top Gun: Maverick

Top Gun: Maverick: a legacy sequel that soars on real stunts and old-fashioned heart

Top Gun: Maverick is a thrilling, beautifully crafted blockbuster with superb practical action and a surprisingly moving story. Its familiar plot, underdeveloped supporting characters and thin romance keep it from greatness in dramatic terms, but as a piece of big-screen entertainment it is exceptional, and it more than justifies its return to the danger zone.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.