Skip to content

Head to head

Comfortably Numb vs Purple Rain

Purple Rain takes it by 0.3, 9.5 against 9.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Comfortably Numb
Comfortably Numb

1979 · Essential

  • David Gilmour's closing solo is a masterclass in melody and tone
  • The contrast between Waters' flat verses and Gilmour's soaring choruses
  • Its slow tempo and six-minute length can feel heavy on its own
Cover of Purple Rain
Purple Rain

1984 · Masterpiece

  • A live club take kept almost whole, room noise and all
  • The last three minutes belong to a guitar, not a lyric
  • Eight minutes and forty-one seconds is a real commitment

Where the gap is

Production
9.19.2
Performance
9.69.8
Songwriting
9.39.4
Replay value
8.89.3

At a glance

FactComfortably NumbPurple Rain
Released30 November 197925 June 1984
ArtistPink Floyd, Scissor SistersPrince, The Revolution
AlbumThe WallPurple Rain
Length6:238:41
GenreProgressive rock · RockPop · Rock · Soul
Label—Warner Bros. Records, Warner Records

The two verdicts

Comfortably Numb

Comfortably Numb: Pink Floyd's bleakest ballad and the solo that crowns it

A 9.2 reflects a song in which two very different writers pulled in the same direction for six minutes, with one of rock's most admired solos as the payoff. It would sit higher still if it did not lean so heavily on The Wall's story for its full effect, and if the orchestra did not occasionally swell a little too far.

Read the full review →

Purple Rain

Purple Rain: a club benefit in Minneapolis that turned into a hymn

The score reflects a record that does something almost nobody attempts and then gets away with it: a slow, plain, eight-minute ballad, cut live in a club with a new guitarist on her first night, released essentially as played, and allowed to end with three minutes of guitar instead of a chorus. The songwriting is deliberately ordinary and the lyric is thin on the page, which is the only thing keeping it from a perfect mark. Everything else — the build, the vocal that gives up its composure on purpose, the solo, the coda that hands the song away — is as well judged as popular music gets. It is the rare standard that still sounds like an event rather than a fixture.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.