Skip to content
Song reviewMasterpiece#2 in songs

Purple Rain · 1984

Purple Rain: a club benefit in Minneapolis that turned into a hymn

Purple Rain review. Prince and the Revolution cut the album version live at First Avenue in 1983, and never found a reason to record it again.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Masterpiece

Editorial score out of 10

Most famous songs are built in a studio and then taken on the road. "Purple Rain" went the other way. What reached number two on the American singles chart in the autumn of 1984 is, underneath the overdubs, a recording of a benefit concert in a Minneapolis club, played by a band whose new guitarist had joined the line-up that night. The tape was tidied, thickened and trimmed. It was never replaced.

9.5
Editorial score
#2
Of 38 songs reviewed
1984
Released
8:41
Length

That origin explains almost everything about how the song behaves. It takes nearly two minutes to reach its first chorus, and it spends its last third on a guitar solo and a wordless massed vocal that no radio programmer would have designed. It is also the most durable thing Prince made, and the piece he came back to at the end of nearly every concert he played afterwards. The reason is not the chorus. It is that the record still sounds like a room.

A benefit, a tape

First Avenue is a converted bus depot near the edge of downtown Minneapolis, and on 3 August 1983 it hosted a benefit for the Minnesota Dance Theatre. Prince treated the evening as a working session. The producer David Z. recorded it with a mobile unit brought in from the Record Plant in New York, on the understanding that what came out of the night might be a live album, might be part of a film, and might be neither. Three of the songs that ended up on the Purple Rain album came from that tape. The title track is the one that never needed a second attempt.

It was also Wendy Melvoin's first show with the Revolution. She is credited on the record with electric rhythm guitar, and the chords she plays are the first thing anyone hears: an arpeggio held open, unhurried, ringing into a room that has no idea yet what it is about to get. Nothing on the recording works harder to establish the mood, and almost nothing about it is clever. It is simply somebody playing slowly in a big space with the tape running.

  1. August 1983

    Recorded live at First Avenue, Minneapolis, at a Minnesota Dance Theatre benefit

  2. Late 1983

    Overdubs and a string arrangement added at Sunset Sound in Los Angeles

  3. June 1984

    Released as the closing track of the Purple Rain album

  4. September 1984

    Issued as the album's third single, backed with "God"

  5. 2007

    Played in actual rain to close the Super Bowl XLI halftime show

  6. April 2016

    The last song of Prince's final concert, in Atlanta

What survives of that night on the finished record is the thing studios usually spend money removing. The crowd is audible. The band is not perfectly in step. The overdubs, added months later on the other side of the country, sit on top of a performance rather than replacing it, and the seam is never hidden. For a producer as controlling as Prince, who played most of the instruments on his earlier albums himself, leaving this one alone was the decision.

Purple Rain
Purple RainMehendri Solon, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What it actually is

Take the arrangement away and "Purple Rain" is a slow ballad with a handful of chords, three short verses that barely move, and a chorus consisting of one phrase said over and over until it stops being a sentence and becomes a wish. Prince was uneasy enough about how familiar the changes felt that he asked Jonathan Cain of Journey, who had written "Faithfully", to listen to it. Cain told him the two songs shared a few chords and nothing else. He was right, and the worry is still instructive: the song's materials are ordinary on purpose.

It did not start there. It was first written as a country song, and intended as a collaboration with Stevie Nicks. What remains of that is the pacing — the long lines, the room left between them, the sense of a ballad sung to one person rather than a hall. The lyric is a set of apologies to someone who was never going to be talked round, addressed under a sky that has turned an end-of-the-world colour.

Purple rain pertains to the end of the world and being with the one you love, and letting your faith guide you through the purple rain.

— Prince

The apocalypse in that line is not decoration. The title track of 1999, two years earlier, had already described a sky gone all purple on judgement day, and this song is the same weather seen from much closer. In the film, it does a second job: each verse points at a different relationship the main character has broken, and the performance of it is the moment he stops refusing to say so. That is a lot of work for a lyric that, written out flat, runs to about a page.

Watch
Purple Rain — trailer

The arrangement

The strings are the tell. They were arranged by Prince with Lisa Coleman, conducted by Coleman and Melvoin, and they do not arrive until the song has already established that it can hold a room without them. Matt Fink's electric grand piano sits low in the mix and keeps the harmony honest. Brown Mark's bass is content to play roots. Bobby Z.'s drums are half machine and half kit, which in 1983 was the sound of the immediate future and now reads as a period detail that has aged unusually well.

Everything in the production is in service of a single curve. The record starts quiet, adds one element per section, and does not reach full volume until the vocal has stopped. The released version is also shorter than what the club heard that night; the edit happened after the fact, in the same spirit as the overdubs, tightening a performance rather than improving it.

How it sits

Patience required
8/10
Nearly two minutes before the first chorus
Room in the mix
9/10
The live tape is audible under every overdub
Lyrical density
4/10
Three short verses and one repeated phrase
Guitar
10/10
The final third belongs to it entirely
Singalong
9/10
The coda is written for a crowd, not a listener

The seven-inch edit released to radio is a competent piece of surgery and a completely different proposition. It keeps the verses, keeps a chorus, and amputates the part of the record that justifies the rest. Anyone who knows the song only as a four-minute ballad has heard the setup and not the payoff.

Gallery · 3 imagesWarner Bros. Records, via Cover Art Archive · penner, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Scott Penner, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The performance

Prince sings the first verse close to the microphone, almost conversationally, and then spends the next six minutes taking the same melody further out. By the last chorus he is at the top of his range and fraying, and the fraying is the point; the control he shows everywhere else in his catalogue is deliberately let go here. Few singers with that much technique are willing to sound like they are losing.

Then the guitar takes over, and the song stops arguing in words. The solo is unusually patient for a rock climax: it begins low, repeats a short figure until it means something, and only reaches for the high notes once the listener has stopped expecting them. It quotes the vocal melody rather than escaping it. Prince was a guitarist long before most audiences noticed, and this is the recording that made the point unmissable.

The wordless coda that follows is a choir part written for people who have never heard it. That trick is old — [Hey Jude](/item/hey-jude) proved a decade earlier that a repeated syllable can outlast a lyric — but few songs earn the ending as completely, because here the crowd on the tape is already doing it.

Why it lasts

It has survived every context it has been put in. It closed the album, closed the film, and then closed thousands of concerts without ever becoming a formality. Prince played it in a downpour at the Super Bowl halftime show in 2007, a coincidence that should have been embarrassing and instead became the performance the event is remembered for. After his death in 2016, it returned to the charts on both sides of the Atlantic, was sung at vigils, and was covered on stage by Bruce Springsteen.

Part of that durability is structural. The song is built to be finished by other people: the coda has no words to get wrong, the melody sits where most voices can reach it, and the arrangement is simple enough that a bar band can play it and a stadium can carry it. Part of it is that the record keeps a secret in plain sight — it is a live recording, and a listener can hear that without knowing it, which is why it never sounds like a product.

For you if

  • Anyone who wants to hear what a guitar solo is for
  • Listeners who will give a ballad eight minutes to make its case
  • Anyone curious how gospel structure got onto an eighties pop chart

Not for you if

  • Anyone who wants the hook early and the record over in three minutes
  • Listeners who find studio polish reassuring and room noise sloppy
  • Anyone put off by a song they have already heard in every supermarket

If the eight-minute version is new territory, the obvious next step is the record it closes, where the same band plays much faster and much filthier for forty minutes before arriving here. Failing that, the catalogue has one other single that refused to be cut down for radio and won the argument.

The closest relative in the catalogue is not a pop single at all. Pink Floyd's ballad ends the same way, with a guitar taking over from a voice that has said everything it can, and the two solos make an instructive pair: one built from grief and restraint, the other from release.

Head to head

Production
9.29.1
Performance
9.89.6
Songwriting
9.49.3
Replay value
9.38.8

Purple Rain edges it by 0.3. See them side by side

Where they part company is the room. [Comfortably Numb](/item/comfortably-numb) is a studio construction of extraordinary precision, assembled from takes. "Purple Rain" is one evening, kept.

What works

  • A live club take kept almost whole, room noise and all
  • The last three minutes belong to a guitar, not a lyric
  • A gospel shape smuggled onto a pop chart at full length
  • A coda written for a crowd to finish rather than a singer

What doesn’t

  • Eight minutes and forty-one seconds is a real commitment
  • The lyric is slight on the page; the performance does the arguing
  • Four decades of exposure have worn the strangeness off the opening
MasterpieceHow we score

The verdict

The score reflects a record that does something almost nobody attempts and then gets away with it: a slow, plain, eight-minute ballad, cut live in a club with a new guitarist on her first night, released essentially as played, and allowed to end with three minutes of guitar instead of a chorus. The songwriting is deliberately ordinary and the lyric is thin on the page, which is the only thing keeping it from a perfect mark. Everything else — the build, the vocal that gives up its composure on purpose, the solo, the coda that hands the song away — is as well judged as popular music gets. It is the rare standard that still sounds like an event rather than a fixture.

Quick answers

Is Purple Rain worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Purple Rain (1984) 9.5 out of 10 — masterpiece. The score reflects a record that does something almost nobody attempts and then gets away with it: a slow, plain, eight-minute ballad, cut live in a club with a new guitarist on her first night, released essentially as played, and allowed to end with three minutes of guitar instead of a chorus. The songwriting is deliberately ordinary and the lyric is thin on the page, which is the only thing keeping it from a perfect mark.

Who will enjoy Purple Rain?

Anyone who wants to hear what a guitar solo is for. Listeners who will give a ballad eight minutes to make its case. Anyone curious how gospel structure got onto an eighties pop chart.

Who should skip Purple Rain?

Anyone who wants the hook early and the record over in three minutes. Listeners who find studio polish reassuring and room noise sloppy. Anyone put off by a song they have already heard in every supermarket.

What is Purple Rain like, in short?

The album version is a live take from First Avenue, overdubbed rather than re-recorded. It began as a country song, and was first meant as a collaboration with Stevie Nicks. The shape is gospel: slow build, long release, a coda handed to the crowd. The guitar solo is the argument, and it starts after the lyric has run out.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Purple Rain yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for songs: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.