Skip to content
Song reviewEssential#3 in songs

Running Up That Hill · 1985

Running Up That Hill: a machine, a sample and a bargain nobody can make

Running Up That Hill review. Kate Bush built her 1985 single from a Fairlight sample and a drum machine, and Stranger Things gave it a second life.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet10 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Kate Bush wanted to call it "Deal with God". EMI looked at the radio stations of Catholic Europe, decided the title would keep the record off them, and in August 1985 the song went out as "Running Up That Hill", its original name folded into brackets on the album sleeve that followed six weeks later. Bush has called the change a compromise she regrets, and has said the song is still "Deal with God" to her.

9.4
Editorial score
#3
Of 38 songs reviewed
1985
Released
4:58
Length

That is the anecdote. It is not the reason the record works. "Running Up That Hill" is a pop single assembled from a sampled cello, a drum machine and one idea repeated until it aches, and it spends every second of its length refusing to let any of them settle. The harmony will not resolve. The drums never break. The voice reaches for a note at the top of each chorus, fails to own it, and goes back for it again. It is a song about wanting to be somebody else, built so that the wanting never arrives.

A deal, a title

The song arrived in a single evening in 1983, in the room where Bush wrote: a piano, a Fairlight CMI and an eight-track machine. Having put the profits of four albums into a forty-eight-track studio built in a barn at East Wickham Farm, on the south-eastern edge of London, she could take the demo apart across months with no studio clock running against her. What came out sounds nothing like a demo and everything like someone with unlimited time and nobody to answer to.

Her own title was the argument. "A Deal with God" names a transaction: a price, a counterparty, a thing asked for. "Running Up That Hill" names only the effort. The label's objection was practical rather than pious — a record with God in the title would be kept off the air across several markets, and a lead single nobody will play is not a lead single. Bush agreed, and has regretted agreeing ever since.

  1. 1983

    Written in one evening, on piano and Fairlight, in Bush's writing room

  2. 1984

    Recorded at her own forty-eight-track studio at East Wickham Farm, Welling

  3. 5 August 1985

    Released by EMI as the lead single from Hounds of Love; number three in Britain

  4. 16 September 1985

    The album follows, with the bracketed title restored

  5. August 2012

    A new remix is heard at the closing ceremony of the London Olympics

  6. 27 May 2022

    Stranger Things hands the song to a teenager with a Walkman

  7. 17 June 2022

    Number one in Britain, thirty-seven years after it first charted

Both titles are accurate, which is the problem. The hill is the effort of understanding another person. The deal is what that effort would actually cost. Strip the brackets and it becomes a song about exertion; keep them and it becomes a song about bargaining with something that does not bargain.

Running Up That Hill
Running Up That HillPaul Carless, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What the Fairlight does

The opening figure is the most recognisable thing Bush ever recorded, and almost nobody hears it correctly. It is not a cello. It is a cello sample on a Fairlight CMI, played from a keyboard, doubled and stacked until it stops behaving like a bowed instrument and starts behaving like a hammer. In the first sketch that part was a harp. Changing the sound did the work a rewrite usually does: a harp suggests floating, and a sampled cello suggests being dragged.

Underneath sits a drone that is not an instrument at all. A chord was played into a Quantec digital reverb and frozen there, and the held tone runs beneath the whole record like a pedal note nobody is holding down. That is why the track feels airless. The key is C minor, the melody keeps landing on the minor seventh rather than the root, and on the word "could" — the hinge of the entire lyric — the vocal sits a major seventh above the chord under it. The song is engineered to be a fraction wrong at the precise moment it asks for something.

How it sits

Tension
10/10
Nothing resolves, from the first bar to the fade
Harmonic movement
3/10
One figure, one key, almost no chord changes
Density
6/10
Fewer parts than it sounds, all mixed very close
Vocal strain
8/10
The top of each chorus is audibly a reach
Singalong
7/10
One line everybody knows, and it is a conditional
Watch
Running Up That Hill — trailer

The drum pattern

Bush sang the drum part aloud and Del Palmer programmed it into a LinnDrum, which is a detail worth keeping straight: the pattern is not a preset, and the machine is not the LM-1 that people often name. It is a sung phrase transcribed onto a box, which is why it moves in a way early-eighties programming usually does not. The toms answer the bass rather than the other way round. Palmer played that bass as well, and the two parts sit so close in the mix that they read as one pulsing instrument.

Exactly one real drum makes it onto the record. Stuart Elliott overdubbed a snare on top of the LinnDrum's, because the machine alone could not carry the weight of the chorus, and it is the only moment where the arrangement admits it needs muscle. Alan Murphy's electric guitar turns up at the very end and does nothing clever, simply thickening the run-out. Paddy Bush's balalaika is buried so far down that most listeners have heard it a thousand times without ever identifying it.

None of that is a credit list for its own sake. The point is how little is there. A sampled cello, a machine, a bass, one overdubbed snare, a guitar at the end and a voice — that is the whole record, and it fills more space than arrangements three times the size.

Gallery · 3 imagesPaul Carless, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons · EMI Records, via Cover Art Archive · Publicity photograph distributed by the record company, 1985; public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

What the lyric argues

The lyric is a proposal, and it is unusually precise about its terms. The narrator does not want to leave, apologise or be forgiven. She wants an exchange, her position for his and his for hers, on the grounds that neither party can be argued out of a misunderstanding while they remain themselves. That is a colder thought than pop lyrics normally risk, and the song states it as a conditional rather than a wish: if only she could, she would.

It's about a relationship between a man and a woman. They love each other very much, and the power of the relationship is something that gets in the way.

— Kate Bush

What stops this being a debating point is the singing. By 1985 Bush had left behind the high, mannered delivery of her first records for something lower and closer to speech, and here she uses the bottom of that register for the verses before pushing the choruses to a place where the voice audibly costs her something. The strain is not buffed out of the mix. It is the evidence that the deal would be worth making.

The video argues the same case without a word. Bush and a male dancer move as a single body, mirroring, catching and failing to catch, choreography standing in for the question of whether two people can ever occupy the same position. The sleeve took its image from that film: a figure drawing a bow, aiming at nothing the viewer can see.

The second life

In 2022 [Stranger Things](/item/stranger-things) put the song on a cassette in a teenager's Walkman and made it the thing keeping her alive. The choice belonged to the music supervisor Nora Felder, working from scripts that had carried a placeholder where the song should be. Bush, who almost never licenses her work to television, approved it, and then watched what happened from the far side of thirty-seven years.

The results are a matter of record rather than legend. The single reached number three in Britain in 1985 and number thirty in America. On 17 June 2022 it went to number one in Britain for the first time, and the Official Charts Company logged three records at once: the longest gap between an artist's chart-topping singles, forty-four years after "Wuthering Heights"; the oldest woman ever to top the chart; and the longest a single has taken to get there. In America it climbed to number three, her first top ten in that country.

More interesting than the chart is why this song and not another. Television usually revives old records as period signals — put a 1985 single over a scene set in 1986 and the audience reads the year without being told. This one was used as a lifeline instead, played at length while the drama stopped to let it. It survived the treatment because it was already built for it: a fixed pulse, a held tone, a voice running uphill and a chorus consisting entirely of a bargain.

For you if

  • Anyone who wants to hear how much one sampled sound can carry
  • Listeners who like a pop record that refuses to resolve
  • Anyone curious what a musician does with a studio of her own

Not for you if

  • Anyone who needs a chorus to release the tension it builds
  • Listeners who have had this song in every advert and trailer since 2022
  • Anyone put off by eighties drum machines on principle

The natural next step is the album it opens, where the same room and the same machines go somewhere considerably stranger across a whole second side. Before that, though, there is the placement that started all of this.

For Bush's own account of the revival there is only one reliable address.

The nearest relative in the catalogue is not another synthesiser record. It is a British single that spent years as a fixture before a screen placement turned it back into an event.

Head to head

Production
9.69.6
Performance
9.39.5
Songwriting
9.59.5
Replay value
9.29.0

Dead level: both score 9.4.See them side by side

The difference is what the screen did. [Bohemian Rhapsody](/item/bohemian-rhapsody) was already a monument, and a film comedy reminded everyone it was fun. "Running Up That Hill" was a well-liked hit that had never topped anything, and one television sequence made the case for it that 1985 had missed.

What works

  • A sampled cello and a drum machine doing the work of a full band
  • A lyric that states its bargain in one line and never softens it
  • Tension built for five minutes and deliberately never released
  • A vocal that strains on purpose, mixed so the strain is audible

What doesn’t

  • The bracketed title still describes the song better than the real one
  • Saturation since 2022 has worn down how strange it once sounded
  • The fade stops the argument rather than settling it
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

The score is for a record that solves a problem most writers avoid: how to build a song around an unbearable wish without ever granting the listener relief. The answer is architectural — a frozen chord under everything, a key that does not modulate, a drum pattern with no fill to break it, a melody that keeps choosing the wrong note on purpose. It is also an unusually pure piece of authorship, written, produced and arranged by one person in a room she paid for herself. What keeps it a notch below the top is the fade, which stops the argument rather than answering it, and the fact that the name on the label has never described the song half as well as the one in brackets.

Quick answers

Is Running Up That Hill worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Running Up That Hill (1985) 9.4 out of 10 — essential. The score is for a record that solves a problem most writers avoid: how to build a song around an unbearable wish without ever granting the listener relief. The answer is architectural — a frozen chord under everything, a key that does not modulate, a drum pattern with no fill to break it, a melody that keeps choosing the wrong note on purpose.

Who will enjoy Running Up That Hill?

Anyone who wants to hear how much one sampled sound can carry. Listeners who like a pop record that refuses to resolve. Anyone curious what a musician does with a studio of her own.

Who should skip Running Up That Hill?

Anyone who needs a chorus to release the tension it builds. Listeners who have had this song in every advert and trailer since 2022. Anyone put off by eighties drum machines on principle.

What is Running Up That Hill like, in short?

Bush wrote it, produced it, arranged it and cut it at her own studio at East Wickham Farm. The cello figure everybody hums is a Fairlight CMI sample, and it started life as a harp. The drums are a LinnDrum pattern she sang aloud for Del Palmer to programme. The lyric proposes a trade: let a man and a woman change places and understand each other.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Running Up That Hill yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for songs: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.