Like a Rolling Stone · 1965
Like a Rolling Stone: six minutes that broke the rules of the pop single
Like a Rolling Stone review. Bob Dylan's 1965 single turned a ten-page rant into a six-minute hit and changed what a pop record was allowed to be.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
A snare hit, then a band that sounds as though it has only just agreed on the key. That is how "Like a Rolling Stone" opens, and within a minute it has made the case that a pop single can carry the weight of a short novel. Bob Dylan recorded it in June 1965, Columbia Records nearly shelved it for being too long, and by the end of the summer it was sitting at number two in the United States, held off the top only by the Beatles.
- 9.7
- Editorial score
- #1
- Of 38 songs reviewed
- 1965
- Released
- 6:13
- Length
Sixty years on, the song is easier to admire than to hear, because so much of what followed it took its lessons for granted. Strip the reputation away and what is left is still startling: a six-minute record with no love story, four verses of withering address to someone who has lost everything, and a chorus that asks the same question until the asking becomes a kind of release. It remains the best argument for the idea that rock music could be literature without stopping being loud.
Context
By the spring of 1965 Dylan was the most celebrated songwriter of the American folk revival, and by his own account he was close to giving up. The tour of England captured in Dont Look Back had left him drained and irritated with what audiences expected of him. Back home he began typing a long, shapeless piece of verse, ten pages by one of his descriptions and twenty by another, which he later called a kind of vomit. Out of it came a chorus, then four verses, worked into shape at a piano in Woodstock.
He had already plugged in on part of Bringing It All Back Home earlier that year, so the electric band was not a surprise in itself. What was new was the scale. Pop singles of the period were built to fit under three minutes, and radio programmers planned around that. Dylan brought a song to the studio that could not be told in that space without losing its point, and he would not cut it down.
Spring 1965
Tour of England, filmed for Dont Look Back; Dylan considers quitting
June 1965
Draft cut down to four verses and a chorus in Woodstock
15–16 June 1965
Sessions at Columbia Studio A, New York; take four becomes the master
20 July 1965
Released as a single, with Gates of Eden on the B-side
25 July 1965
First live performance, with an electric band at the Newport Folk Festival
30 August 1965
Opens the album Highway 61 Revisited

Songwriting
The song is built as an address. Someone who once had every advantage, the good schools and the right friends, has fallen into a world where none of it counts, and the singer walks through her decline verse by verse, naming the people who used her and the comforts that turned out to be props. Read on the page the verses are harsh, close to gloating. The listener is invited to enjoy her fall, and for the first two verses it is easy to accept the invitation.
Then the chorus does its work. It is a single question, repeated, about what it feels like to be alone and unknown, and every time it comes round the tone shifts a little further from mockery towards recognition. By the end it is no longer clear whether the singer is taunting her, envying her freedom from everything she owned, or speaking to himself. Dylan never resolved that ambiguity in interviews, once joking that he simply wanted to needle people, and the song is stronger for leaving it open.
The imagery around the central figure is crowded and strange: tramps, diplomats, jugglers and clowns who sound as if they have wandered in from a carnival or a tarot deck. None of them needs decoding to work. They give the song the texture of a city seen from the gutter, and they set a template for the surreal, character-stuffed writing that would run through the rest of Highway 61 Revisited and the albums after it.
The session
The first day of recording, 15 June, produced a slow version in three-four time with Dylan at the piano. It is a curiosity now, issued years later on a Bootleg Series collection, and it shows a song that had not yet found its body. The next day the band switched to four-four, Dylan picked up an electric guitar, and the arrangement locked. Tom Wilson, producing what turned out to be his last session with Dylan, liked the fourth take enough to say so on tape. It became the single.
The organ part is the session's famous accident. Al Kooper, twenty-one and invited as a guest, was not supposed to play, and was barely an organist. He sat down at the Hammond anyway and played a line a fraction behind the beat, feeling for each chord as it came. Wilson objected when Dylan asked for it to be turned up in the mix. Dylan won, and the hesitant, churchy figure that resulted became the record's signature.
How it measures up
- Lyrical density
- 9.5/10
- Four long verses with barely a line wasted
- Arrangement looseness
- 8/10
- Players finding the song as they play it
- Vocal attack
- 9.5/10
- Every line pushed, none crooned
- Radio-friendliness in 1965
- 3/10
- Too long, too sour, too loud for the format
- Influence on what followed
- 10/10
- Changed what a single was allowed to be
Around Kooper sits a band of New York session players and one Chicago blues guitarist. Mike Bloomfield had been told before the sessions to leave out the blues string-bending he was known for, and his part is all short, stinging fills. Paul Griffin's piano rolls underneath, Bobby Gregg's drums drive rather than swing, Joe Macho Jr. holds the bass to the root, and Bruce Langhorne shakes a tambourine. The mix is dense and slightly muddy, and the organ sometimes swamps the guitar. That crowding is part of the excitement: it sounds like a room full of people trying to keep up with the singer.
Performance
Dylan's vocal is the reason the song survives the reverence it now receives. He does not sing the verses so much as push them out, stretching some syllables and clipping others, landing hard on the end of each line as if daring the band to cut in. The voice is young, nasal and sardonic, and it carries contempt and sympathy at once. When the chorus arrives, he rises into it with something like glee, and the harmonica breaks between verses are short and raw rather than decorative.
The way that Elvis freed your body, Bob freed your mind. He showed us that just because the music was innately physical, it did not mean that it was anti-intellect.
Onstage the song became a battleground. At Newport, five days after the single came out, a short, uncertain electric set drew boos from part of the crowd, though how much of that was about the volume and how much about the brevity is still argued. On the 1966 tour of Britain it closed the electric half of every show, and at Manchester's Free Trade Hall a listener shouted a single word of betrayal at him before the band began. The performance that followed, louder and angrier than the studio take, is the other essential version.
Why it lasts
Columbia's sales department did not want to release a six-minute single. According to Shaun Considine, then a release coordinator at the label, the record was only rescued after an acetate was played at a New York club and radio programmers began asking for it. Early promotional copies split the song across both sides of the disc; listeners and disc jockeys pushed for the full take on one side. Once it charted, the three-minute ceiling on the pop single began to look like a habit rather than a law.
| Version | Year | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Original single and album take | 1965 | The master from the second day; start here |
| Studio rehearsal in three-four | 1965 | The song before it found its shape, on The Bootleg Series Vol. 2 |
| Manchester, Free Trade Hall | 1966 | Louder and more defiant, on The Bootleg Series Vol. 4 |
| Jimi Hendrix Experience at Monterey | 1967 | Slowed down and reworked as heavy blues |
| MTV Unplugged | 1994 | A mellower late reading for a television audience |
The longer singles that followed, from the Beatles' [Hey Jude](/item/hey-jude) to the operatic sprawl of [Bohemian Rhapsody](/item/bohemian-rhapsody), did not need permission from Dylan, but they arrived into a business that had already seen a long, strange record reach number two. Rolling Stone, a magazine that took part of its name from the song, placed it first on its list of the greatest songs of all time in 2004 and again in 2010. Dylan's handwritten manuscript sold at Sotheby's in 2014 for two million dollars.
Ranking aside, what keeps the song alive is that it never settles. Each listen tilts the balance between scorn and compassion a little differently, and the arrangement still sounds as though it might fall apart in the next bar. It invites argument about who it is addressed to, and it rewards the listener who gives up trying to decide.
Head to head
- Production
- 8.88.8
- Performance
- 9.89.1
- Songwriting
- 9.99.3
- Replay value
- 9.48.6
Like a Rolling Stone edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
Both songs run far past the three-minute norm and both proved that radio would play them anyway, but they want opposite things. One consoles and lifts; this one confronts and unsettles, and leaves the listener to choose between pity and contempt.
For you if
- Anyone who wants to hear the point where folk songwriting and rock volume met
- Listeners who like lyrics that argue with themselves and reward rereading
- Fans of loose, live-sounding records where the band is audibly finding the song
Not for you if
- Anyone who needs a pop song to be warm, tidy or reassuring
- Listeners put off by a nasal, deliberately unpretty vocal
- Those who want polished production; the mix is crowded and rough at the edges
For listeners coming to Dylan for the first time, the song is the obvious door, and it opens straight onto the album it introduces.
What works
- A chorus that turns contempt into something close to sympathy over four verses
- Al Kooper's organ line, played by a guest who was not meant to be in the room
- Dylan's vocal leans on every line as if the band might stop him
- Runs past six minutes and never sags; the length is the argument
What doesn’t
- The mix is rough, with the organ and guitar crowding the voice in places
- The scorn in the verses can feel cruel to a listener who wants comfort
- Decades of reverence make it hard to hear fresh on a first listen
The verdict
Few records have changed the terms of their own medium as directly as this one, and it is the reason the score sits above every other song in the catalogue. "Like a Rolling Stone" proved that a hit could be long, bitter, wordy and ambiguous, and it did so with a performance that still sounds alive rather than embalmed. The score sits in the top tier for the writing and the vocal, which are as good as popular music gets, and for the way the band's half-rehearsed urgency became the song's identity. It falls short of a perfect mark only because the recording itself is rough, and because sixty years of canonisation can make it feel like homework before it feels like a song. Get past that, and the question at its centre lands as hard as it did in 1965.





