Skip to content

Head to head

Hey Jude vs Like a Rolling Stone

Like a Rolling Stone takes it by 0.7, 9.7 against 9.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Hey Jude
Hey Jude

1968 · Essential

  • A warm, reassuring melody that feels instantly timeless
  • McCartney's vocal builds from gentle comfort to unrestrained release
  • The four-minute coda can outstay its welcome on repeated plays
Cover of Like a Rolling Stone
Like a Rolling Stone

1965 · Masterpiece

  • A chorus that turns contempt into something close to sympathy over four verses
  • Al Kooper's organ line, played by a guest who was not meant to be in the room
  • The mix is rough, with the organ and guitar crowding the voice in places

Where the gap is

Production
8.88.8
Performance
9.19.8
Songwriting
9.39.9
Replay value
8.69.4

At a glance

FactHey JudeLike a Rolling Stone
Released26 August 196820 July 1965
ArtistThe Beatles, Wilson PickettBob Dylan
AlbumSingleHighway 61 Revisited
Length7:116:13
GenrePop · RockRock · Folk rock
Label—Columbia Records

The two verdicts

Hey Jude

Hey Jude: a song of comfort that grows into a whole world singing along

Hey Jude earns a 9.0 for a melody of rare warmth and an ending that turns private consolation into a crowd event. The coda that made it famous is also its weak point on repeat listens, and McCartney's late screaming is more exuberance than music, but few songs have been so generous to their listeners.

Read the full review →

Like a Rolling Stone

Like a Rolling Stone: six minutes that broke the rules of the pop single

Few records have changed the terms of their own medium as directly as this one, and it is the reason the score sits above every other song in the catalogue. "Like a Rolling Stone" proved that a hit could be long, bitter, wordy and ambiguous, and it did so with a performance that still sounds alive rather than embalmed. The score sits in the top tier for the writing and the vocal, which are as good as popular music gets, and for the way the band's half-rehearsed urgency became the song's identity. It falls short of a perfect mark only because the recording itself is rough, and because sixty years of canonisation can make it feel like homework before it feels like a song. Get past that, and the question at its centre lands as hard as it did in 1965.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.