Skip to content

Head to head

The Dark Forest vs Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary takes it by 0.1, 8.6 against 8.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Dark Forest
The Dark Forest

2008 · Excellent

  • The Wallfacer premise turns secrecy into a gripping strategic puzzle
  • Its central theory of cosmic civilisations is chilling and memorable
  • Luo Ji's idealised romance subplot is awkward and dated
Cover of Project Hail Mary
Project Hail Mary

2021 · Excellent

  • Scientific puzzles are explained clearly and make the plot exciting
  • An unexpected central friendship is funny, touching and inventive
  • Grace's relentless quips can feel juvenile and grating

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.78.9
Story
8.88.9
Writing
7.57.3
Characters
6.98.4

At a glance

FactThe Dark ForestProject Hail Mary
Released1 May 20084 May 2021
AuthorLiu CixinAndy Weir
PublisherChongqing Publishing GroupBallantine Books
Pages400476
GenreSci-FiSci-Fi

The two verdicts

The Dark Forest

The Dark Forest: Liu Cixin's bleak cosmic chess game outdoes its predecessor

The Dark Forest is a bigger, bolder and better-constructed book than its predecessor, driven by a superb premise and a truly haunting central idea. Flat characters, a clumsy romantic thread and stiff exposition keep it from greatness on every front, but as a work of speculative imagination it is exceptional, and it lifts the whole trilogy with it.

Read the full review →

Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary: Andy Weir's problem-solving thriller finds a big, warm heart

Project Hail Mary is an exceptionally entertaining novel that combines clever scientific problem-solving with genuine emotional warmth. Its prose is plain, its humour can be grating and its exposition is heavy, but its inventiveness and heart outweigh those flaws comfortably. It is Weir's most satisfying book to date and an excellent example of optimistic, puzzle-driven science fiction.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.