Skip to content

Head to head

Daytripper vs Scott Pilgrim

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Daytripper
Daytripper

2010 · Excellent

  • A bold structural conceit that reframes each chapter as a question about meaning
  • Moon and Ba's fluid, expressive art makes Brazil vivid and specific
  • The recurring device grows predictable before the final chapters
Cover of Scott Pilgrim
Scott Pilgrim

2004 · Excellent

  • Fights drawn with the clarity of a manga action page and the logic of a cartridge game
  • A Toronto of real bars, libraries and shops that the jokes are built around
  • Scott is hard company for the first two volumes, by design but at a cost

Where the gap is

Art
9.39.0
Story
8.68.4
Pacing
8.48.1
Characters
8.38.9

At a glance

FactDaytripperScott Pilgrim
Released3 February 201018 August 2004
WriterFábio MoonBryan Lee O'Malley
ArtistGabriel BáBryan Lee O'Malley
PublisherDC ComicsOni Press
Issues10Six digest volumes, published by Oni Press between 18 August 2004 and 20 July 2010
GenreDrama · Graphic NovelAction · Comedy · Romance

The two verdicts

Daytripper

Daytripper uses one man's many endings to make ordinary life feel luminous

Daytripper is a tender, visually rich meditation on mortality, anchored by a structure that constantly reframes what an ordinary life can hold. Predictability in the middle, thin female characters and moments of over-sweet narration hold it back from the very top rank. An 8.7 honours an excellent, deeply felt graphic novel that many readers will find genuinely life-affirming.

Read the full review →

Scott Pilgrim

Scott Pilgrim: a slacker romance drawn like a boss fight, and wiser than it looks

Scott Pilgrim earns its reputation by being two things at once: a fast, funny comic about punching people in Toronto, and a slow-building story about a young man learning that his memory flatters him. The art grows up alongside its hero, the supporting cast is drawn with real affection, and the fights remain some of the most readable action in Western comics of the period. It falls short of the top tier because the plot machinery of the final stretch is thinner than the emotions it carries, and because the early volumes ask readers to put up with Scott before they understand why. Those are the costs of a series made over six years by a cartoonist working out what it was about. The result is still one of the defining comics of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.