Skip to content

Head to head

Dexter vs Reacher

Dead level: both score 7.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Dexter
Dexter

2006 · Good

  • Michael C. Hall makes a killer's inner monologue darkly compelling
  • The fourth season, with John Lithgow, is gripping antihero drama
  • Later seasons repeat the villain-of-the-year formula with diminishing returns
Cover of Reacher
Reacher

2022 · Good

  • Alan Ritchson embodies Reacher's size, intellect and dry wit perfectly
  • Brutal, clearly staged fight scenes deliver real pulp satisfaction
  • Villains and conspiracies are generic and predictable

Where the gap is

Craft
7.37.3
Story
6.86.9
Characters
7.47.0
Performances
8.47.7

At a glance

FactDexterReacher
Released1 October 20064 February 2022
Created byJames Manos JrNick Santora
StarringMichael C. Hall, Jennifer Carpenter, David ZayasAlan Ritchson, Malcolm Goodwin, Willa Fitzgerald
NetworkShowtimeAmazon Prime Video
Seasons82
Episodes9616
GenreDrama · Crime · MysteryAction · Drama · Crime

The two verdicts

Dexter

Dexter: a thrilling antihero study that squandered its best years

Dexter scores 7.3 as a whole: its best seasons deserve considerably more, thanks to Hall's defining performance and some excellent plotting, but the steep decline in its second half and a notoriously weak finale drag the complete series down. It remains an influential, often thrilling show that is best remembered selectively.

Read the full review →

Reacher

Reacher: a blunt, satisfying pulp thriller that finally casts the right giant

Reacher earns a 7.3 for Alan Ritchson's perfect casting, satisfying action and faithful adaptation of a beloved hero. Its generic villains, predictable plots and slow stretches of exposition keep it from rising above good pulp entertainment, but as a no-nonsense action series, it delivers.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.