Skip to content

Head to head

Disco Elysium vs Red Dead Redemption 2

Dead level: both score 9.5. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Disco Elysium
Disco Elysium

2019 · Masterpiece

  • Some of the sharpest, funniest and saddest writing in the medium
  • Skills as inner voices make character building feel like characterisation
  • An enormous amount of reading that demands sustained attention
Cover of Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2

2018 · Masterpiece

  • Arthur Morgan is one of the richest, most complex protagonists in games
  • An astonishingly detailed world full of unscripted encounters and life
  • Heavy, deliberate controls and long animations can feel sluggish

Where the gap is

Story
9.89.8
Gameplay
8.98.5
Longevity
9.09.4
Presentation
9.29.9

At a glance

FactDisco ElysiumRed Dead Redemption 2
Released15 October 201926 October 2018
DeveloperZA/UMRockstar Games, Rockstar San Diego
PublisherZA/UM, Spike ChunsoftRockstar Games
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, Nintendo SwitchPC (Windows), PlayStation 4, Xbox One
EngineUnityRAGE
GenreRPG · IndieAction · Adventure · Open world

The two verdicts

Disco Elysium

Disco Elysium is a detective story where the real crime scene is the detective himself

Disco Elysium earns a landmark score for writing, character and ideas that stand among the best in any medium. A demanding reading load and a slightly compressed final act are minor imperfections in a game that redefined what role-playing can mean.

Read the full review →

Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a slow, devastating elegy for the outlaw West

Red Dead Redemption 2 combines a breathtakingly detailed world with a profoundly moving central story and a protagonist who ranks among gaming's best. Its heavy controls, rigid missions and slow opening are real drawbacks, but the ambition, craft and emotional power of the whole mark it as a landmark of the medium.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.