Skip to content

Head to head

Dune vs The Vegetarian

Dead level: both score 9.2. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Dune
Dune

1965 · Essential

  • Arrakis is one of the most thoroughly imagined worlds in fiction
  • Weaves ecology, religion, economics and politics into one plot
  • Italicised inner thoughts and stiff dialogue make the prose feel dated
Cover of The Vegetarian
The Vegetarian

2007 · Essential

  • Prose so plain that the violence arrives without a raised voice
  • Three narrators who indict themselves while explaining Yeong-hye
  • The middle section's sexual content will lose readers, by design

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.89.5
Story
9.28.6
Writing
8.29.4
Characters
8.38.8

At a glance

FactDuneThe Vegetarian
Released1 August 196530 October 2007
AuthorFrank HerbertHan Kang
PublisherChilton Company, DebolsilloChangbi Publishers
Pages688247 pages
GenreAdventure · Sci-FiDrama · Literary fiction · Psychological

The two verdicts

Dune

Dune: the desert epic that made ecology and empire the stuff of science fiction

Dune's prose shows its age and its villains lack nuance, but those are small debts against what it achieves. Its world is unparalleled in depth, its fusion of ecology, faith and power remains unmatched, and its critique of heroic leadership grows more pointed over time. It is an exceptional novel and one of science fiction's foundational works.

Read the full review →

The Vegetarian

The Vegetarian: a refusal narrated by everyone except the woman refusing

*The Vegetarian* earns its reputation by doing one hard thing perfectly: it takes a premise that could have been a fable and refuses every explanation that would make it comfortable. The prose is plain to the point of austerity, the structure turns three ordinary narrators into an indictment of themselves, and the whole thing fits in an afternoon and then refuses to leave. It falls short of the very top only because the strategy has a price. Yeong-hye is kept at arm's length for so long that the novel occasionally risks becoming the silence it is describing, and the second part will end the book for some readers on the page it begins. Those are the terms. For anyone able to accept them, this is as good as short fiction gets.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.