Skip to content

Head to head

East of West vs Preacher

Dead level: both score 7.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of East of West
East of West

2013 · Good

  • Nick Dragotta's clean, graphic art makes Death one of comics' coolest designs
  • An audacious setting that mixes westerns, dystopia and biblical prophecy
  • A huge cast of scheming leaders leaves little room for emotional depth
Cover of Preacher
Preacher

1995 · Good

  • An audacious premise that takes on religion, America and masculinity
  • Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy form a vivid, messy and loyal central trio
  • Gross-out gags and homophobic jokes have aged poorly

Where the gap is

Art
9.18.2
Story
7.67.9
Pacing
6.97.0
Characters
7.08.4

At a glance

FactEast of WestPreacher
Released27 March 20131 April 1995
WriterJonathan HickmanGarth Ennis
ArtistNick DragottaGlenn Fabry, Steve Dillon
PublisherImage ComicsVertigo
Issues4566
GenreSci-Fi · Fantasy · WesternAction · Drama · Black comedy

The two verdicts

East of West

East of West is a stunning apocalyptic western that keeps its readers at arm's length

East of West is a visually superb, conceptually rich epic that deserves credit for its sheer audacity and for finishing its story. Its enormous cast, stately pacing and preference for pronouncements over people keep it from the top tier. A 7.8 reflects a good and often dazzling series whose emotional pull does not match its ambition.

Read the full review →

Preacher

Preacher is a profane, blasphemous road trip with a surprisingly old-fashioned heart

Preacher is a bold, funny and genuinely affecting series, powered by three terrific central characters and a willingness to ask big questions about faith and morality. Its dated shock humour, meandering middle and conflicted view of masculinity hold it back. A 7.8 reflects a good, often brilliant series that time has not treated kindly.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.