Skip to content

Head to head

Erased vs Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World

Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World takes it by 0.2, 7.9 against 7.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Erased
Erased

2016 · Good

  • An outstanding opening run that blends suspense with childhood nostalgia
  • Satoru and Kayo's bond is written with tenderness and restraint
  • The final episodes feel rushed and diverge from the manga's fuller story
Cover of Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World
  • Return by Death makes failure genuinely painful instead of a reset
  • Unflinching look at trauma, guilt and a hero's self-loathing
  • Subaru is abrasive enough to drive some viewers away early

Where the gap is

Sound
8.48.0
Story
7.38.1
Animation
8.17.9
Characters
8.27.8

At a glance

FactErasedRe:Zero − Starting Life in Another World
Released8 January 20164 April 2016
StudioA-1 PicturesWHITE FOX
DirectorYūichirō Hirakawa, Tomohiko Itō—
Episodes1250
StatusCompletedAiring
GenreDrama · Mystery · SuspenseDrama · Fantasy · Isekai

The two verdicts

Erased

Erased: a superb time-travel mystery that runs short of breath at the finish

Erased is a gripping, beautifully crafted thriller whose opening episodes rank among the most compelling of their era. Its compressed finale, predictable mystery and underdeveloped present-day thread prevent it from reaching the heights its first half promised. It was widely popular on release and remains a common recommendation, and a 7.7 reflects a good series with an excellent start and notable issues.

Read the full review →

Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World

Re:Zero: the isekai that makes its hero pay for every second chance

Re:Zero earns its score by making a familiar genre feel dangerous, and by committing to the emotional damage its premise implies. An abrasive lead, bloated stretches in the second season and uneven tone keep it below the top tier, but its best episodes are gripping and its willingness to hurt its hero sets it apart from most of its peers.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.