Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World · 2016
Re:Zero: the isekai that makes its hero pay for every second chance
Re:Zero - Starting Life in Another World review: White Fox's dark isekai turns a save-point power into punishing drama, though its pacing and tone are uneven.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Re:Zero arrived in 2016 as part of a flood of stories about ordinary young men transported into fantasy worlds, and it quickly stood out by treating that premise as a source of horror rather than wish fulfilment. Its protagonist does get a special power, but it is one that forces him to die repeatedly and remember every moment.
- 7.9
- Editorial score
- #68
- Of 93 anime reviewed
- 2016
- Released
- 50
- Episodes
The result is a darker, more emotionally punishing series than its colourful setting suggests, though one with real weaknesses in pacing and tone.
Kenichiro Suehiro's score is a strength, particularly its haunting, choral cues during moments of despair, and the opening themes capture the show's urgency.
Death as a save point
The concept, which the series calls Return by Death, is essentially a game mechanic turned into drama. Subaru dies, returns to a fixed point and has to work out what went wrong. Early arcs use this to build mysteries: who killed him, why, and how to prevent it. Because he cannot explain his power without dire consequences, he is isolated in his knowledge, and the people he saves often have no idea what he endured for them.
The series is strongest when it explores the psychological cost. Deaths are painful and frequently gruesome, and the repetition wears Subaru down. A sequence late in the first season in which he reaches a breaking point, followed by a long, cathartic conversation with the maid Rem, is widely regarded as one of the best stretches in the genre.

A hero who is hard to like
Subaru is the show's most divisive element. In early episodes he is loud, self-centred and oblivious, and his behaviour towards Emilia can be entitled. That is clearly deliberate; the series is interested in exposing his flaws and making him confront them. But viewers who find him grating in the opening arc may not stay long enough to see him change.
The supporting cast is lively. Emilia is kind but guarded, Rem and her twin sister Ram are memorable, and the eccentric nobles backing the royal candidates add colour. Rem's popularity with fans became a phenomenon, sometimes at the expense of Emilia, whose depth emerges more slowly.
Seasons and structure
The first season is a sequence of distinct arcs with clear goals, and it flows well despite the occasional slow episode. The second season, split into two parts, takes a very different approach. Its Sanctuary storyline is dense with backstory, mind games and extended dialogue scenes, some lasting most of an episode. For some fans it represents the series at its richest; for others it is exhausting and hard to follow.
The tone can also be jarring. Moments of comic fan service and cute character beats sit beside grisly deaths and psychological torment, and the shifts do not always feel intentional.
Look and sound
White Fox's production is generally solid, with bright fantasy environments and expressive character animation. Action sequences are well staged but not the main attraction, and quality varies across seasons. Kenichiro Suehiro's score is a strength, particularly its haunting, choral cues during moments of despair, and the opening themes capture the show's urgency. The Japanese voice cast, especially Subaru's performer during his breakdowns, gives the drama real force.
What works
- Return by Death makes failure genuinely painful instead of a reset
- Unflinching look at trauma, guilt and a hero's self-loathing
- Standout episodes deliver some of the genre's most intense drama
- Well-built mysteries that reward attention across loops
What doesn’t
- Subaru is abrasive enough to drive some viewers away early
- Second season's dense exposition and long dialogues slow the story
- Gory shock and fan-service moments sit awkwardly with its serious themes
Head to head
- Sound
- 8.08.4
- Story
- 8.17.3
- Animation
- 7.98.1
- Characters
- 7.88.2
Re:Zero − Starting Life in Another World edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Re:Zero earns its score by making a familiar genre feel dangerous, and by committing to the emotional damage its premise implies. An abrasive lead, bloated stretches in the second season and uneven tone keep it below the top tier, but its best episodes are gripping and its willingness to hurt its hero sets it apart from most of its peers.





