Skip to content

Head to head

Fourth Wing vs The Midnight Library

The Midnight Library takes it by 0.1, 6.7 against 6.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Fourth Wing
Fourth Wing

2023 · Mixed

  • Relentless pacing and short chapters make it genuinely hard to put down
  • Violet's chronic physical fragility gives the survival plot fresh stakes
  • Modern slang and sarcasm clash with the military fantasy setting
Cover of The Midnight Library
  • An instantly appealing high-concept premise about roads not taken
  • Brisk, short chapters make it quick and easy to read
  • Its central lesson is obvious long before Nora reaches it

Where the gap is

Ideas
5.86.8
Story
7.26.9
Writing
5.96.4
Characters
6.56.2

At a glance

FactFourth WingThe Midnight Library
Released2 May 202313 August 2020
AuthorRebecca YarrosMatt Haig
PublisherEntangled PublishingCanongate Books
Pages498288
GenreFantasy · RomanceFantasy · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

Fourth Wing

Fourth Wing: a breathless dragon-school romance that runs on adrenaline, not depth

Fourth Wing succeeds as pure entertainment: fast, dramatic and addictive, with an appealing heroine and delightful dragons. But its world is shallow, its prose uneven and its romance built from well-worn parts. Its enormous popularity is understandable, yet as a novel it lands in mixed territory, enjoyable more for its momentum than its craft.

Read the full review →

The Midnight Library

The Midnight Library: a comforting fable of second chances that plays it too safe

The Midnight Library is a kind, comforting book built on an appealing idea, and it clearly resonates with many readers. Its predictable arc, thinly realised alternate lives and reliance on platitudes, though, keep it firmly in mixed territory. It is pleasant and sometimes touching, but rarely more than a gentle reminder of truths most readers already know.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.