Skip to content
Book reviewMixed

The Midnight Library · 2020

The Midnight Library: a comforting fable of second chances that plays it too safe

Matt Haig's The Midnight Library follows Nora Seed through lives she might have lived. Warm and accessible, but its insights feel familiar and predictable.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Mixed

Editorial score out of 10

The Midnight Library became a runaway bestseller, and its central idea explains why. Who has not wondered how life might have turned out with a different career, partner or city? Matt Haig turns that universal question into a gentle fantasy, offering his heroine the chance to try out her alternatives one by one.

6.7
Editorial score
#59
Of 61 books reviewed
2020
Released
288
Pages

It is a warm, well-meaning book that many readers have found consoling. As a novel, though, it rarely surprises.

Nora often spends only a few pages in each before discovering its drawbacks, and the rhythm of arrival, disappointment and departure becomes repetitive.

The premise

Nora's situation at the start is bleak. She feels she has failed at everything, from a promising swimming career to a band she abandoned, and she carries guilt towards her family and friends. The book deals openly with suicidal feelings, which frames the library as a liminal space rather than a whimsical escape. Readers should be aware of this subject matter, although Haig, who has written candidly about his own experiences of depression, handles it with evident care.

The library itself is a charming conceit, with endless shelves of green books and a Book of Regrets that grows heavier with every disappointment. The guide who oversees it, a figure Nora knew as a child, gives the setting a sense of warmth and nostalgia.

The Midnight Library
The Midnight LibraryEdition cover via Open Library

Lives in miniature

The novel's structure is essentially episodic. Nora tries a life as a scientist in the Arctic, a rock star touring the world, a champion swimmer, a pub owner, a mother and more. Some of these episodes have genuine charm, particularly her time among glaciers and polar bears, where the vivid landscape provides a welcome change of pace and tone.

Many other lives are sketched quickly, however. Nora often spends only a few pages in each before discovering its drawbacks, and the rhythm of arrival, disappointment and departure becomes repetitive. The alternate versions of her family and friends rarely develop into full characters, which limits the emotional stakes.

Message over mystery

Haig's interest is clearly in the lesson Nora learns about regret, happiness and the value of an ordinary existence. This lesson is humane, and some readers will find it genuinely helpful. But it is also visible very early, and the book repeats it through aphorisms and philosophical reflections that sometimes read like quotations on a greeting card. Nora's background in philosophy is used to introduce ideas, but these are rarely explored beyond the surface.

The prose is clear and friendly, and the short chapters make it very readable. Yet the simplicity that makes it accessible also makes it slight.

Gallery · 3 imagesEdition cover via Open Library

Who it is for

It suits readers looking for an uplifting, easy-to-read novel with a high-concept premise and a hopeful message, and it has become a popular choice for book groups. Those seeking complex characters, ambiguity or fresh philosophical insight may find it underwhelming. Readers affected by depression should be aware of its themes, which are handled compassionately but directly.

What works

  • An instantly appealing high-concept premise about roads not taken
  • Brisk, short chapters make it quick and easy to read
  • Handles depression and loneliness with visible compassion
  • Some alternate lives are vivid, including an Arctic research posting

What doesn’t

  • Its central lesson is obvious long before Nora reaches it
  • Many alternate lives are sketched too briefly to feel real
  • Philosophical musings often read like inspirational quotations

Head to head

Ideas
6.89.3
Story
6.98.8
Writing
6.49.5
Characters
6.28.7

Piranesi edges it by 2.4. See them side by side

MixedHow we score

The verdict

The Midnight Library is a kind, comforting book built on an appealing idea, and it clearly resonates with many readers. Its predictable arc, thinly realised alternate lives and reliance on platitudes, though, keep it firmly in mixed territory. It is pleasant and sometimes touching, but rarely more than a gentle reminder of truths most readers already know.

Quick answers

Is The Midnight Library worth reading?

Voxizer scores The Midnight Library (2020) 6.7 out of 10 — mixed. The Midnight Library is a kind, comforting book built on an appealing idea, and it clearly resonates with many readers. Its predictable arc, thinly realised alternate lives and reliance on platitudes, though, keep it firmly in mixed territory.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed The Midnight Library yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for books: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.