Skip to content

Head to head

Piranesi vs The Midnight Library

Piranesi takes it by 2.4, 9.1 against 6.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Piranesi
Piranesi

2020 · Essential

  • A narrator whose capitalised nouns do the worldbuilding without a page of exposition
  • The journal form lets the reader assemble a second story from the gaps
  • The explanation underneath is more ordinary than the halls hiding it
Cover of The Midnight Library
  • An instantly appealing high-concept premise about roads not taken
  • Brisk, short chapters make it quick and easy to read
  • Its central lesson is obvious long before Nora reaches it

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.36.8
Story
8.86.9
Writing
9.56.4
Characters
8.76.2

At a glance

FactPiranesiThe Midnight Library
Released15 September 202013 August 2020
AuthorSusanna ClarkeMatt Haig
PublisherBloomsbury PublishingCanongate Books
Pages272 pages288
GenreFantasy · Literary fiction · MysteryFantasy · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

Piranesi

Piranesi: a whole world built out of tides, statues and one careful voice

Piranesi earns its reputation on craft rather than scale. A narrator this consistent is difficult to write and nearly impossible to sustain, and Clarke holds the voice for the whole book without stepping outside it once to reassure anyone. What keeps the score just below the top tier is the machinery underneath: the explanation, when it arrives, is a smaller and more ordinary thing than the halls concealing it, and the supporting characters exist largely to deliver it. That trade is worth making. Sixteen years of silence produced a short, strange, startlingly kind novel about what survives when a person has been emptied out, and there is nothing else on the shelf quite this shape.

Read the full review →

The Midnight Library

The Midnight Library: a comforting fable of second chances that plays it too safe

The Midnight Library is a kind, comforting book built on an appealing idea, and it clearly resonates with many readers. Its predictable arc, thinly realised alternate lives and reliance on platitudes, though, keep it firmly in mixed territory. It is pleasant and sometimes touching, but rarely more than a gentle reminder of truths most readers already know.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.