Skip to content

Head to head

From Hell vs Monstress

Dead level: both score 9.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of From Hell
From Hell

1989 · Essential

  • Eddie Campbell's scratchy ink turns Victorian London into a living, filthy nightmare
  • Gives the murdered women a humanity most Ripper fiction ignores
  • Long monologues and slow chapters test even patient readers
Cover of Monstress
Monstress

2015 · Essential

  • Takeda paints every panel, and the standard does not slip across the run
  • A fantasy war whose engine is slavery and race rather than a prophecy
  • The first arc buries its rules in dialogue and expects you to keep up

Where the gap is

Art
8.79.8
Story
9.18.8
Pacing
7.88.2
Characters
9.09.0

At a glance

FactFrom HellMonstress
Released19894 November 2015
WriterAlan MooreMarjorie Liu
ArtistEddie C. CampbellSana Takeda
Issues16Ongoing since November 2015; issues #1–60 collected in ten volumes to December 2025
GenreHistory · Crime · HorrorFantasy · Graphic Novel · Horror
Publisher—Image Comics

The two verdicts

From Hell

From Hell turns the Ripper murders into a hallucinatory autopsy of an empire

From Hell is a monumental, deeply researched and profoundly unsettling work that treats a much-exploited crime with rare intelligence and compassion for its victims. Its punishing pace, reliance on a discredited theory and unrelenting darkness make it hard going, and they account for the gap between this and a perfect score. A 9.0 honours an exceptional graphic novel that very few comics have matched for ambition.

Read the full review →

Monstress

Monstress: the best-looking comic on the shelf asks a great deal in return

*Monstress* earns its reputation on the art alone, and then keeps earning it on everything else. Takeda has painted a decade of pages without a visible dip, and Liu has used them for something harder than spectacle: a war story about what happens to people who have been classified as raw material. The score stops short of the top because the first arc is forbidding in a way no editor fixed, and because the middle volumes sometimes mistake the number of factions for the depth of the politics. Neither flaw is fatal, and neither is a surprise in a series this ambitious. For anyone prepared to read slowly and be confused for a while, it is among the two or three finest ongoing comics being published.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.