Monstress · 2015
Monstress: the best-looking comic on the shelf asks a great deal in return
Monstress review. Marjorie Liu and Sana Takeda's Image Comics epic pairs painted art of a rare standard with a world that takes real work to enter.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Most comics are built to be read quickly. Monstress is built to be looked at. Sana Takeda paints every panel of it, in ivory and ash and tarnished gold, inside art nouveau borders, around machines that look grown rather than assembled, and the effect is that the eye stops before the words arrive. Ten volumes into its run the series still moves at the pace of a novel rather than a monthly. That is the best thing about it and the reason it loses some readers inside fifty pages.
- 9.0
- Editorial score
- #17
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Art
Marjorie Liu has written a world to match. A human empire is at war with the Arcanics, magical people who sometimes pass for human; a religious order called the Cumaea renders captured Arcanics down into the substance that powers its magic; the war has settled into something worse than fighting, which is a trade. Into that she drops Maika Halfwolf, a teenager missing her left arm, looking for the truth about her dead mother, and carrying something in the stump that is hungry. None of this is a superhero comic, and none of it is gentle.
The premise
Volume 1, Awakening, opens with Maika for sale. She has let herself be taken so that she can get inside the house of a woman who might know what happened to her mother, which tells you most of what you need about how this series operates: the plot moves through places where people are bought, and Maika is nearly always the most dangerous person in the room while having almost no control over the thing that makes her dangerous. The first six issues are an escape, a pursuit, and the opening round of an argument between Maika and the voice inside her about who is using whom.
The setting draws on early twentieth-century Asia rather than medieval Europe, and it is run by women: the Cumaea's abbesses, the Arcanic courts, the queens who started the war. That is not decoration. Almost every hand on a lever in this story belongs to a woman, which means the cruelty belongs to women too, and Liu has no interest in letting a matriarchy off the hook for it. The politics feel invented for this book rather than borrowed from somewhere older.
2013
Liu brings the idea to Takeda, after the two worked together on Marvel's X-23
2015
Image Comics publishes the oversized first issue in November
2016
Awakening collects the first six issues
2017
Awakening wins the Hugo Award for Best Graphic Story
2018
The series takes the Eisner for Best Continuing Series and the Harvey Book of the Year
Those awards matter mostly as a measure of how fast the thing was recognised: the first collected volume was decorated before the second arc had finished shipping. What they do not tell a new reader is how steep the opening is.

Liu's script
The first volume front-loads everything. Names, factions, species, a cosmology of Ancients, a war with dates attached, and most of it arrives in dialogue between characters who already know it. A talking cat delivers a history lecture in the back of each issue, which is charming and is also an admission that the story could not carry the exposition unaided. Readers who give up on Monstress almost always give up here.
Push through, because from the second volume onwards Liu writes some of the strongest political fantasy in the medium. She is very good at the scene in which two people who loathe each other have to negotiate, and better at the one in which an atrocity is discussed as policy. The dialogue is dry, fast and unusually free of fantasy diction. The horror is moral before it is physical: the question the book keeps circling is what a person becomes once everyone around them has agreed that she is meat.
Takeda does not draw backgrounds. She draws places that were lived in long before anyone in the story got there.
That is the other half of the argument, and on most pages it is the half doing the heavy lifting.
Takeda's pages
Her line came out of manga and her colour came out of painting, and the series sits between the two. The faces and the panel-to-panel storytelling read as Japanese; the density and the ornament read as European; the borders are art nouveau without apology. She works in a narrow palette of bone, rust, smoke and a gold that always looks tarnished, then lets a single red or green carry an entire scene. It is a comic identifiable from across a room.
The detail is doing work, too. Armour, tattoos, prosthetics and the pattern on a sleeve all say something about who a character is and what she is owed, and the monsters are built with anatomical logic rather than assembled out of teeth. The cost is legibility. A fight in a crowded room can be hard to follow at speed, and there are pages where ornament and lettering compete for the same space. Rus Wooton's letters do more than most readers will notice to keep those pages readable.
How it reads
- Art density
- 10/10
- Painted throughout, with almost nothing left flat
- Story density
- 9/10
- Factions, Ancients and family history, often on one page
- Welcome to newcomers
- 5/10
- The first arc explains its rules late and only partly
- Violence
- 8/10
- Severe, and almost always consequential
Maika and Kippa
Maika is not likeable and is not written to be. She is angry, secretive, ungrateful to the people who help her, and willing to do appalling things for information about her mother. What makes her work is that the comic never asks for a pass on her behalf. The people she hurts stay hurt, and the story keeps score.
Kippa does the rest. A small Arcanic fox-child who attaches herself to Maika early and cannot be shaken off, she is the one uncomplicated kindness in the book, and Liu uses her with care: as the reason a reader keeps caring, and as the thing most obviously at risk in a world that sells children. It is a manipulation. It is also executed well enough that saying so out loud changes nothing.
The supporting cast around those two keeps growing, and that is where the middle of the run wobbles. Courts, orders and rival houses accumulate faster than the page count can serve them, and there are stretches where Maika disappears into a war council for most of a volume.
Pacing and format
Read monthly, this is a hard series to keep hold of: the issues are dense, the gaps between arcs have been long, and a cliffhanger three months old is a cliffhanger you will have to look up. Read in collected volumes, it is close to ideal. Liu writes to the trade paperback, and each volume has a shape, a turn and an ending rather than a stopping point.
| Volume | Issues collected | Published |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Awakening | #1–6 | July 2016 |
| 2. The Blood | #7–12 | July 2017 |
| 3. Haven | #13–18 | September 2018 |
| 4. The Chosen | #19–24 | September 2019 |
| 5. Warchild | #25–30 | October 2020 |
| 6. The Vow | #31–35, with Talk-Stories | September 2021 |
| 7. Devourer | #36–41 | September 2022 |
| 8. Inferno | #42–48 | November 2023 |
| 9. The Possessed | #49–54 | November 2024 |
| 10. Hollow Gods | #55–60 | December 2025 |
There are hardcovers collecting three volumes at a time and a compendium that gathers the first eight, and either is a better object for this particular art than a stack of paperbacks. The compendium is also the cheapest way in by a wide margin, at the price of a brick you cannot comfortably read in bed.
The obvious shelf-mate is Image's other long-running creator-owned fantasy epic, and the two make an instructive pair: one built on warmth and a narrator's voice, the other on ornament and withheld information.
Head to head
- Art
- 9.89.2
- Story
- 8.88.7
- Pacing
- 8.27.8
- Characters
- 9.09.3
Monstress edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
Saga is the friendlier book and the funnier one. Monstress is the more beautiful and the more disciplined, and it asks for a reader who is happy to be lost for a while. Anyone who liked the political machinery of Paper Girls or the world-building of Saga has the right reflexes for it.
Where to start
Start at volume 1 and read the first two volumes as one unit. Awakening alone is not a fair test; the second volume is where the exposition stops and the story takes over, and a reader who stops after six issues will have had all of the homework and little of the payoff. Skim the cat lectures the first time and come back to them later, when the names mean something.
For you if
- Readers who want fantasy politics without a chosen one or a prophecy
- Anyone who reads comics for the art first and will sit with a page
- Fans of dense, matriarchal world-building with real moral weight
Not for you if
- Anyone who wants a story explained as it goes
- Readers who need a protagonist to be sympathetic
- Anyone who cannot take sustained cruelty to children on the page
If that reads like an invitation rather than a warning, the publisher's own page is the tidiest map of what exists and in what format.
What works
- Takeda paints every panel, and the standard does not slip across the run
- A fantasy war whose engine is slavery and race rather than a prophecy
- Kippa, the fox-child, gives all that cruelty something to push against
- Each collected volume lands a real turn instead of stalling for the next one
What doesn’t
- The first arc buries its rules in dialogue and expects you to keep up
- Faction politics crowd the characters out for stretches of the middle volumes
- The violence done to children is relentless and will put some readers off
The verdict
Monstress earns its reputation on the art alone, and then keeps earning it on everything else. Takeda has painted a decade of pages without a visible dip, and Liu has used them for something harder than spectacle: a war story about what happens to people who have been classified as raw material. The score stops short of the top because the first arc is forbidding in a way no editor fixed, and because the middle volumes sometimes mistake the number of factions for the depth of the politics. Neither flaw is fatal, and neither is a surprise in a series this ambitious. For anyone prepared to read slowly and be confused for a while, it is among the two or three finest ongoing comics being published.




