Skip to content

Head to head

Getting Killed vs Lemonade

Dead level: both score 8.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Getting Killed
Getting Killed

2025 · Excellent

  • A rhythm section recorded loud and forward, so the grooves carry the songs
  • Cameron Winter's voice moves from croon to shriek inside a single verse
  • The middle stretch sags when two long grooves sit back to back
Cover of Lemonade
Lemonade

2016 · Excellent

  • Beyoncé's most emotionally raw and commanding vocal performances
  • A strong narrative arc from suspicion and fury to healing
  • Some of its impact depends on the accompanying film

Where the gap is

Cohesion
8.48.7
Production
8.69.0
Performance
9.39.4
Songwriting
8.98.9

At a glance

FactGetting KilledLemonade
Released26 September 202523 April 2016
ArtistGeeseBeyonce
LabelPartisan Records, PIAS RecordingsParkwood Entertainment, Columbia Records
Tracks1112
Length45:3545:42
GenreIndie · Art rock · RockHip-hop · Pop · R&B

The two verdicts

Getting Killed

Getting Killed: Geese sound like a band that has stopped asking permission

*Getting Killed* is the record on which Geese stop sounding like a clever band with influences and start sounding like themselves. The decision to cut it fast, play it loud and leave the seams showing gives it an urgency that most rock albums of its year lacked, and a rhythm section this good earns the space it is given. The score stops short of essential because the middle stretch drifts, the lyrics too often settle for strangeness over meaning, and Winter's delivery is a toll some listeners will not want to pay. Those reservations are real. They are also the cost of an album that takes risks a more careful band would have avoided, and almost every one of those risks pays off.

Read the full review →

Lemonade

Lemonade: Beyoncé turns betrayal into a genre-spanning statement of power

Lemonade scores 8.8 as an excellent, era-defining album. Its performances are among the finest in modern pop, its narrative is compelling, and its cultural resonance is profound. It falls just short of the exceptional tier because a few tracks feel more like connective moments than fully developed songs, and because some of its power depends on the visual work that accompanies it. As a statement of artistic and personal independence, it remains remarkable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.