Skip to content

Head to head

Half-Life 2 vs Red Dead Redemption 2

Dead level: both score 9.5. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Half-Life 2
Half-Life 2

2004 · Masterpiece

  • The Gravity Gun turns every crate, saw blade and radiator into a weapon or a step
  • City 17 tells its own history through posters, checkpoints and broadcasts
  • The two long vehicle chapters overstay what their driving can support
Cover of Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2

2018 · Masterpiece

  • Arthur Morgan is one of the richest, most complex protagonists in games
  • An astonishingly detailed world full of unscripted encounters and life
  • Heavy, deliberate controls and long animations can feel sluggish

Where the gap is

Story
8.89.8
Gameplay
9.68.5
Longevity
9.19.4
Presentation
9.59.9

At a glance

FactHalf-Life 2Red Dead Redemption 2
Released16 November 200426 October 2018
DeveloperValveRockstar Games, Rockstar San Diego
PublisherValveRockstar Games
PlatformsPC (Windows), macOS, LinuxPC (Windows), PlayStation 4, Xbox One
EngineSourceRAGE
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · FPSAction · Adventure · Open world

The two verdicts

Half-Life 2

Half-Life 2: the shooter that made physics part of the plot

Half-Life 2 earns its place in the top tier not because it has aged gracefully, though mostly it has, but because so much of what it did first has become the way the genre works. Physics as a tool rather than a decoration, a world that explains itself through its streets, supporting characters with faces that can act, and a campaign that keeps changing what it asks of you: all of that is here, in a game released in 2004. The vehicle chapters run long, the soldiers are dull next to everything around them, and the story deliberately withholds more than some players will accept. None of that changes what it is. Two decades on, it remains one of the best-paced games ever made, and an essential stop for anyone who wants to understand where the modern shooter came from.

Read the full review →

Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a slow, devastating elegy for the outlaw West

Red Dead Redemption 2 combines a breathtakingly detailed world with a profoundly moving central story and a protagonist who ranks among gaming's best. Its heavy controls, rigid missions and slow opening are real drawbacks, but the ambition, craft and emotional power of the whole mark it as a landmark of the medium.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.