Skip to content

Head to head

Hamnet vs The Irishman

Dead level: both score 8.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Hamnet
Hamnet

2025 · Excellent

  • Jessie Buckley's Agnes is physical, strange and funny before she is ever tragic
  • Shakespeare is kept to the edges, so the household is the story rather than the backdrop
  • The middle stretch lingers on suffering long enough to feel punishing rather than earned
Cover of The Irishman
The Irishman

2019 · Excellent

  • Joe Pesci's quiet, controlled Russell Bufalino is a revelation
  • Al Pacino's volcanic, funny Jimmy Hoffa gives the film enormous energy
  • Digital de-ageing is often distracting, especially in physical scenes

Where the gap is

Craft
8.98.4
Story
8.28.4
Direction
8.69.2
Performances
9.59.2

At a glance

FactHamnetThe Irishman
Released29 August 20251 November 2019
DirectorChloé ZhaoMartin Scorsese
StarringZac Wishart, James Lintern, Justine MitchellRobert De Niro, Al Pacino, Bobby Cannavale
Runtime126 minutes209 minutes
StudioAmblin Partners, Hera Pictures—
GenreDrama · Romance · HistoryDrama · History · Crime

The two verdicts

Hamnet

Hamnet: a film about grief that keeps its eyes on the mother, not the poet

*Hamnet* is a film about loss that understands loss is mostly made of ordinary days, and it spends its first hour building those days so carefully that the second hour has somewhere to fall from. Zhao's naturalism and Żal's photography make the sixteenth century feel close enough to touch, and Buckley's performance is the kind that defines a career. The score sits below the top tier because the film's middle stretch mistakes duration for depth, and because William, for all Mescal's charm, never becomes the equal partner the marriage needs. Those are real limits. They do not stop it from being one of the most affecting films of its year, and one that earns every tear it asks for.

Read the full review →

The Irishman

The Irishman: Scorsese's mob epic becomes a long, sombre reckoning

The Irishman is a masterful, elegiac late-career work with outstanding performances and a devastating final act. Its inconsistent de-ageing effects, sprawling middle and underused female characters keep it below Scorsese's very best films, but it remains a profound and haunting reflection on violence, loyalty and regret.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.