Skip to content

Head to head

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT vs Mayhem

Dead level: both score 8.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of HIT ME HARD AND SOFT
HIT ME HARD AND SOFT

2024 · Excellent

  • Songs flow into one another like movements in a larger suite
  • Finneas's production shifts mood and genre without losing coherence
  • Several tracks change direction midway, sometimes at the melody's expense
Cover of Mayhem
Mayhem

2025 · Excellent

  • Hooks that land on first play, then reveal odd corners on the fifth
  • Live-band weight under the synths gives the dance tracks real bite
  • The back half repeats its tempos and loses some of the front half's surprise

Where the gap is

Cohesion
8.67.7
Production
9.08.8
Performance
8.78.9
Songwriting
8.58.3

At a glance

FactHIT ME HARD AND SOFTMayhem
Released17 May 20247 March 2025
ArtistBillie EilishLady Gaga
LabelInterscope Records, DarkroomInterscope Records
Tracks1014
Length43:0053:10
GenreAlternative rock · PopPop · Synth pop · Dance pop

The two verdicts

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT: Billie Eilish and Finneas make pop that flows like a film

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT scores 8.4 as an excellent, cohesive album with a clear artistic vision. The production and sequencing are outstanding, and its best songs combine emotional honesty with sharp craft. A tendency to abandon songs midstream and a couple of tracks that feel underdeveloped hold it back from the highest tier, but it is the most complete statement of Eilish's career so far, and both critics and listeners embraced it.

Read the full review →

Mayhem

Mayhem: Lady Gaga's noisiest pop record, and her most controlled

*Mayhem* is worth hearing for anyone who likes big pop hooks with some grit under them, and it is the Lady Gaga record to pick if you want the theatre and the tunes in one place. It earns its score from the first six songs, a production that sounds like musicians in a room, and a vocal performance with range and conviction. It stops short of the top tier because the second half is more comfortable than adventurous, the lyrics keep returning to the same themes, and the closing duet pulls against the tone of everything before it. Those are small reservations next to the record's strengths. It is a confident, fun, well-made album, and the best Gaga has sounded in years.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.