Skip to content

Head to head

Homogenic vs To Pimp a Butterfly

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Homogenic
Homogenic

1997 · Essential

  • One deliberately narrow palette of strings and beats, held across all ten tracks
  • Jóga and Bachelorette are among the strongest singles of her career
  • Pluto and 5 Years are abrasive enough to stop casual listeners cold
Cover of To Pimp a Butterfly
To Pimp a Butterfly

2015 · Essential

  • A rich blend of jazz, funk and soul played by a stellar band
  • Alright became an enduring anthem of protest and resilience
  • Nearly 80 minutes of dense material makes it demanding to revisit

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.59.3
Production
9.69.4
Performance
9.49.6
Songwriting
9.39.7

At a glance

FactHomogenicTo Pimp a Butterfly
Released20 September 199715 March 2015
ArtistBjörkKendrick Lamar
LabelOne Little Indian Records, Elektra RecordsInterscope Records, Top Dawg Entertainment
Tracks1016
Length43:3278:51
GenreElectronic · Art pop · Trip hopHip-hop · Jazz · Funk

The two verdicts

Homogenic

Homogenic: strings and static in one landscape, and Björk's most complete record

Homogenic is the record on which Björk's ambitions and her means finally matched. The decision to work with only strings and beats could have produced a stiff exercise; instead it yields an album in which every element earns its place and the emotional range runs from fury to tenderness without leaving the same landscape. A couple of slighter songs and a few deliberately abrasive moments keep it just short of the very top tier, and listeners who loved the variety of Post may find it severe. For everyone else it is the essential Björk album, and one of the defining records of the late 1990s.

Read the full review →

To Pimp a Butterfly

To Pimp a Butterfly: Kendrick Lamar's dense, jazz-soaked reckoning with America

To Pimp a Butterfly scores 9.4: an exceptional album, and one of the defining artistic statements of its era. Its songwriting, performances and musical ambition are almost unmatched in modern hip-hop, and its cultural impact has been profound. Its length and density keep it just short of the landmark tier for some listeners, but its achievement is undeniable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.