Skip to content

Head to head

House M.D. vs Lost

House M.D. takes it by 0.1, 7.9 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of House M.D.
House M.D.

2004 · Good

  • Hugh Laurie is magnetic as a genius who is impossible to like and hard to dislike
  • The House and Wilson friendship gives the show a real emotional core
  • The case-of-the-week structure becomes highly repetitive
Cover of Lost
Lost

2004 · Good

  • The character-focused flashback structure is superbly used early on
  • Terry O'Quinn and Michael Emerson give enthralling performances
  • Many mysteries are dropped or answered unsatisfyingly

Where the gap is

Craft
7.68.6
Story
7.07.2
Characters
8.38.5
Performances
9.08.3

At a glance

FactHouse M.D.Lost
Released16 November 200422 September 2004
Created byDavid ShoreDamon Lindelof, J. J. Abrams
StarringHugh Laurie, Lisa Edelstein, Robert Sean LeonardNestor Carbonell, Evangeline Lilly, Elizabeth Mitchell
NetworkFoxABC
Seasons86
Episodes177121
GenreDrama · MysteryAdventure · Drama · Mystery

The two verdicts

House M.D.

House M.D.: a formulaic medical procedural powered by a singular performance

House M.D. earns a 7.9 for Hugh Laurie's outstanding performance, a clever reworking of detective fiction and a central friendship that gives the show real heart. Its repetitive formula, soapier later seasons and underdeveloped supporting cast keep it from the top tier of television drama, but its best episodes remain highly watchable.

Read the full review →

Lost

Lost: the mystery that changed network television, flaws and all

Lost earns a 7.8 for its landmark ambition, a rich ensemble and a remarkable run of seasons in the middle of its life. Its stalling early middle stretch, unresolved mythology and a divisive ending prevent a higher score, but its influence on modern television is undeniable and its best episodes are superb.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.