Lost · 2004
Lost: the mystery that changed network television, flaws and all
Our review of Lost, the ABC island mystery: a gripping, character-rich phenomenon that reshaped TV, even as its mythology frayed towards the end.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Lost was a phenomenon. Its pilot, one of the most expensive of its time, promised cinematic spectacle on network television, and the series that followed kept millions of viewers debating its mysteries every week. It helped usher in an era of serialised, mythology-driven drama and proved that audiences would follow a complex story over years if it gave them characters worth caring about.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #72
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2004
- Released
- 6
- Seasons
Its legacy is also contested. For all its ambition, Lost opened more questions than it could satisfyingly close, and its final season left a large portion of its audience disappointed. The fair verdict lies somewhere between masterpiece and folly.
Michael Emerson, introduced as a captive in the second season, turns the manipulative Ben Linus into a magnificent antagonist.
Story
The first season is gripping. The plane crash is staged with visceral chaos, and the survivors' struggle is laced with small, unsettling mysteries: a monster in the jungle, a French distress signal repeating for years, a hatch buried in the ground. Crucially, the flashbacks reveal who these people were before the crash, and the island becomes a place where their pasts are tested.
The second and third seasons are less consistent. Mysteries multiply, answers are withheld and some episodes feel like stalling, a problem made worse by long network seasons. Once the producers negotiated an end date, the show was reinvigorated. A daring shift in its storytelling device at the end of the third season, a fourth season including the celebrated episode The Constant, and a fifth season that plays boldly with time represent a strong late run. The sixth season's attempt to resolve the mythology while delivering an emotional farewell is where opinion splits most sharply.

Characters and performances
Lost's ensemble is its enduring strength. Terry O'Quinn's John Locke, a man who believes the island has chosen him, is one of the most fascinating characters of the decade. Michael Emerson, introduced as a captive in the second season, turns the manipulative Ben Linus into a magnificent antagonist. Josh Holloway gives Sawyer, the cynical conman, surprising depth, Jorge Garcia makes Hurley the warmest presence on the island, and Henry Ian Cusick's Desmond anchors some of its most affecting episodes. Matthew Fox and Evangeline Lilly are solid as the ostensible leads, although the love triangle surrounding them grows tiresome.
Craft
Filmed in Hawaii, Lost looks consistently terrific, with lush jungle locations and striking set pieces. The production design of the island's hidden stations, retro and faintly sinister, became iconic. Michael Giacchino's orchestral score is one of the best in television, and the show's use of a sharp title card and sudden cut to black became a trademark. The pacing of episodes, often ending on cliffhangers, is expert.
Who it is for
Lost remains rewarding for viewers who enjoy serialised mysteries, ensemble drama and ambitious genre storytelling. Those who need every question answered will find it frustrating. It is best approached as a character drama with a mystery attached, rather than a puzzle with a guaranteed solution.
What works
- The character-focused flashback structure is superbly used early on
- Terry O'Quinn and Michael Emerson give enthralling performances
- Episodes such as The Constant are high points of network drama
- Michael Giacchino's score is lush, mournful and memorable
What doesn’t
- Many mysteries are dropped or answered unsatisfyingly
- The second and third seasons stall before the show's reinvention
- The final season and ending divided the audience sharply
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.67.6
- Story
- 7.27.0
- Characters
- 8.58.3
- Performances
- 8.39.0
House M.D. edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Lost earns a 7.8 for its landmark ambition, a rich ensemble and a remarkable run of seasons in the middle of its life. Its stalling early middle stretch, unresolved mythology and a divisive ending prevent a higher score, but its influence on modern television is undeniable and its best episodes are superb.




