Skip to content

Head to head

How I Met Your Mother vs The Gentlemen

Dead level: both score 7.2. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of How I Met Your Mother
  • Playful narration with flashbacks and running gags rewards attention
  • Neil Patrick Harris turns Barney into a comic tour de force
  • Middle and late seasons tread water to delay the central reveal
Cover of The Gentlemen
The Gentlemen

2024 · Good

  • Theo James and Kaya Scodelario share sharp, flirtatious chemistry
  • The collision of aristocracy and gangland is a fertile comic setup
  • Ritchie's familiar tics, from slick montages to swagger, feel recycled

Where the gap is

Craft
7.87.6
Story
6.66.8
Characters
7.67.3
Performances
8.27.8

At a glance

FactHow I Met Your MotherThe Gentlemen
Released19 September 20057 March 2024
Created byCarter Bays, Craig ThomasGuy Ritchie
StarringJason Segel, Neil Patrick Harris, Cobie SmuldersTheo James, Vinnie Jones, Kaya Scodelario
NetworkCBSNetflix
Seasons91
Episodes2088
GenreComedy · RomanceAction · Comedy · Crime

The two verdicts

How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother: a clever, sentimental sitcom undone by its own long game

How I Met Your Mother earns a 7.2 for its inventive storytelling devices, a loveable cast and a peak run of seasons that are genuinely clever. It is held back by repetitive later years, a wearing central character and a finale that undercut the story it spent so long telling.

Read the full review →

The Gentlemen

The Gentlemen: Guy Ritchie's stylish crime caper swaps cinema for a stately home

The Gentlemen is slick, witty and consistently fun, with charismatic leads and a clever premise. Its loose structure, recycled stylistic flourishes and lack of real stakes keep it from being more than a solid entertainment. A 7.2 reflects a good crime caper that delivers exactly what it promises without ever pushing further.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.