Skip to content

Head to head

Invincible vs The Boys

Invincible takes it by 1.3, 8.4 against 7.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Invincible
Invincible

2003 · Excellent

  • A classic teenage-hero setup that grows into a sweeping galactic epic
  • Ryan Ottley's clean, dynamic art makes the extreme action thrillingly readable
  • A widely criticised sexual-assault storyline is handled carelessly
Cover of The Boys
The Boys

2006 · Good

  • A brilliantly cynical premise about celebrity, capitalism and power
  • Hughie and Butcher make a compelling, increasingly tense double act
  • Relentless sexual humiliation and gore become repetitive rather than sharp

Where the gap is

Art
8.67.8
Story
8.57.2
Pacing
7.66.6
Characters
8.77.5

At a glance

FactInvincibleThe Boys
Released22 January 20031 October 2006
WriterDiana PalmerGarth Ennis
PublisherImage ComicsWildStorm, Panini Comics
Issues14472
GenreAction · SuperheroAction · Black comedy · Superhero
Artist—Darick Robertson

The two verdicts

Invincible

Invincible is the superhero soap opera that dares to follow every consequence

Invincible is a gripping, ambitious and emotionally engaged superhero epic, driven by Ottley's superb art and Kirkman's willingness to let consequences stick. Its sluggish middle, escalating gore and a badly handled assault storyline hold it back from greatness. An 8.4 reflects an excellent modern superhero saga with clear, real flaws.

Read the full review →

The Boys

The Boys comic has a razor-sharp premise and a blunt instrument for a sense of humour

The Boys has a brilliant premise, memorable characters and some genuinely sharp satire about the commodification of heroism. Its reliance on gratuitous shock, blunt humour and uneven pacing limit its impact. A 7.1 reflects a good, provocative series that is often more interested in offending than illuminating.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.