The Boys · 2006
The Boys comic has a razor-sharp premise and a blunt instrument for a sense of humour
The Boys, Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson's savage satire of corporate superheroes, has a brilliant hook and strong characters, but its shock value wears thin.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
The Boys takes a simple, provocative idea and pushes it as far as it will go. What if superheroes were not noble protectors but spoiled, amoral celebrities, owned by a corporation and shielded from consequences? Garth Ennis's answer is savage, profane and frequently disgusting, and at its best it makes a pointed case about power, marketing and the myths people build around strong men.
- 7.1
- Editorial score
- #53
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2006
- Released
- 72
- Issues
The comic is less polished and much cruder than the hit television series it inspired, which many viewers consider an improvement on the source. Read on its own terms, it has real strengths and equally real frustrations.
Many jokes are juvenile, and the satire is frequently blunt, targeting obvious figures rather than probing deeper.
Watching the watchmen
The premise is excellent. Vought-American controls the Seven, a Justice League analogue led by Homelander, and uses superheroes for profit and political influence. The Boys, led by the charismatic, vicious Billy Butcher, are tasked with keeping them in line through blackmail and violence. Hughie, a gentle everyman from Scotland whose likeness was drawn from actor Simon Pegg, is recruited after a devastating encounter with a careless hero.
Hughie is the heart of the book. His discomfort with Butcher's methods, his friendships with Mother's Milk, the Frenchman and the silent Female, and his romance with a young superhero named Annie give the story emotional stakes. Butcher, meanwhile, is a fascinating figure, magnetic and increasingly frightening as his personal vendetta against Homelander becomes clearer.
Robertson's grime
Darick Robertson's art grounds the book. His style is detailed and realistic, which makes the superheroes look like real people in costumes and makes the violence visceral. He is also good at facial expressions, especially Hughie's horror and Butcher's cold smile. When Russ Braun and other artists contribute, the art remains consistent in tone, though Robertson's pages have the strongest personality.
The realism also makes the book's more grotesque moments hard to look at, which is exactly the point, but not always to the story's benefit.
Shock as a strategy
The Boys' biggest weakness is its reliance on shock. Ennis fills the series with sexual assault, degradation and bodily horror, and while this is meant to expose the rot at the heart of superhero culture, it often becomes gratuitous and repetitive. Many jokes are juvenile, and the satire is frequently blunt, targeting obvious figures rather than probing deeper.
The pacing is also uneven. Some arcs, particularly those focused on superhero orgies or extended flashbacks, stall the main narrative. The final act is powerful and restores focus, but getting there requires patience.
Who it is for
The Boys is for adult readers with a strong stomach who enjoy cynical satire and Ennis's style of dark comedy. Fans of the television adaptation may find the comic much harsher and less nuanced, though they will recognise the core characters and ideas. Readers seeking thoughtful deconstruction may prefer Watchmen or Miracleman.
What works
- A brilliantly cynical premise about celebrity, capitalism and power
- Hughie and Butcher make a compelling, increasingly tense double act
- Darick Robertson's grounded art sells both violence and dark comedy
- Homelander is a genuinely chilling satire of the Superman archetype
What doesn’t
- Relentless sexual humiliation and gore become repetitive rather than sharp
- The satire is often blunt and aimed at easy targets
- Middle arcs stall with spin-offs and extended detours
Head to head
- Art
- 7.88.6
- Story
- 7.28.5
- Pacing
- 6.67.6
- Characters
- 7.58.7
Invincible edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
The Boys has a brilliant premise, memorable characters and some genuinely sharp satire about the commodification of heroism. Its reliance on gratuitous shock, blunt humour and uneven pacing limit its impact. A 7.1 reflects a good, provocative series that is often more interested in offending than illuminating.




