Skip to content

Head to head

Jolene vs Running Up That Hill

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Jolene
Jolene

1973 · Essential

  • A narrator who begs instead of threatening, and the song is stronger for it
  • The thumb-picked guitar figure is recognisable from its first two bars
  • The song barely develops; the last verse sits where the first one began
Cover of Running Up That Hill
Running Up That Hill

1985 · Essential

  • A sampled cello and a drum machine doing the work of a full band
  • A lyric that states its bargain in one line and never softens it
  • The bracketed title still describes the song better than the real one

Where the gap is

Production
8.89.6
Performance
9.69.3
Songwriting
9.79.5
Replay value
9.39.2

At a glance

FactJoleneRunning Up That Hill
Released15 October 19735 August 1985
ArtistDolly Parton, Elisabeth AndreassenKate Bush, Within Temptation
AlbumJolene (1974)Hounds of Love
LabelRCA VictorEMI Records
Length2:424:58
GenreCountryPop · Rock · Art pop

The two verdicts

Jolene

Jolene: a plea so exposed it turns jealousy into the most generous song in country music

"Jolene" is close to a perfect record and very close to a perfect song. Parton takes the most worn-out scenario in country music, the woman who might steal your man, and writes it from the only angle that had not been tried: total, admiring vulnerability. The guitar gives that vulnerability a pulse, and her vocal keeps it from curdling into self-pity. The score stops just short of the very top because the arrangement around the core belongs to its year more than the song does, and because the structure, by design, never moves anywhere new. Those are small debts against a record that has outlasted every version made in its image and still sounds, half a century on, like someone asking for something she knows she may not get.

Read the full review →

Running Up That Hill

Running Up That Hill: a machine, a sample and a bargain nobody can make

The score is for a record that solves a problem most writers avoid: how to build a song around an unbearable wish without ever granting the listener relief. The answer is architectural — a frozen chord under everything, a key that does not modulate, a drum pattern with no fill to break it, a melody that keeps choosing the wrong note on purpose. It is also an unusually pure piece of authorship, written, produced and arranged by one person in a room she paid for herself. What keeps it a notch below the top is the fade, which stops the argument rather than answering it, and the fact that the name on the label has never described the song half as well as the one in brackets.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.