Skip to content

Head to head

Kaiju No. 8 vs Tokyo Ghoul

Kaiju No. 8 takes it by 0.1, 6.9 against 6.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Kaiju No. 8
Kaiju No. 8

2024 · Mixed

  • Kafka's age and fading ambitions make him a relatable, uncommon lead
  • Comic moments of Kafka hiding his monstrous form land well
  • Plotting sticks closely to familiar training, exams and hidden-power beats
Cover of Tokyo Ghoul
Tokyo Ghoul

2014 · Mixed

  • A compelling premise about identity, hunger and moral compromise
  • Kaneki's struggle to reconcile his two natures is initially gripping
  • Heavy compression rushes character arcs and important story beats

Where the gap is

Sound
7.28.3
Story
6.66.5
Animation
6.86.8
Characters
7.46.9

At a glance

FactKaiju No. 8Tokyo Ghoul
Released13 April 20244 July 2014
StudioProduction I.G, KharaStudio Pierrot
Episodes1212
StatusAiringCompleted
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · ShonenAction · Seinen · Horror
Director—Shuhei Morita

The two verdicts

Kaiju No. 8

Kaiju No. 8: a likeable monster story with a refreshingly grown-up hero

Kaiju No. 8 has a charming lead and a strong premise, but safe storytelling, lacklustre CG and flat visual staging prevent it from reaching its potential. It was one of the most hyped adaptations of its year and received a more muted, mixed-to-positive response than expected. A 6.9 reflects an enjoyable but notably flawed first season.

Read the full review →

Tokyo Ghoul

Tokyo Ghoul: a striking dark fantasy that rushes through its best material

Tokyo Ghoul's score reflects a strong premise and an iconic soundtrack weighed down by rushed pacing, thin supporting characters and disruptive censorship. Its early episodes show what a great adaptation could have been, but as a whole it is a mixed, frustrating experience that works best as an introduction to Sui Ishida's far richer source material.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.