Skip to content

Head to head

Kitchen vs The Alchemist

Kitchen takes it by 2.1, 8.4 against 6.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Kitchen
Kitchen

1988 · Excellent

  • Grief written as tiredness and appetite rather than speeches
  • Eriko, a trans parent drawn with warmth and no sermon, decades early
  • Moonlight Shadow repeats the title story's shape and loses by comparison
Cover of The Alchemist
The Alchemist

1988 · Mixed

  • A simple, graceful fable that is easy to read in one sitting
  • Desert and caravan scenes have an appealing, dreamlike atmosphere
  • Characters are archetypes, and Fatima exists mainly to wait for Santiago

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.46.0
Story
7.86.4
Writing
8.66.6
Characters
8.85.2

At a glance

FactKitchenThe Alchemist
Released30 January 19881988
AuthorBanana YoshimotoPaulo Coelho
TranslatorMegan Backus—
PublisherFukutake ShotenCompanhia das Letras
Pages226 pages197
GenreSlice of Life · Literary fiction · Coming of ageAdventure · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

Kitchen

Kitchen: a small book about grief that finds its comfort in the fridge light

Kitchen is a small book that has outlasted many bigger ones, because it found a way to write about grief without solemnity: through appetite, sleep and the company of people who ask nothing. The title novella and its sequel are close to perfect at what they attempt, and Eriko remains one of the most generous characters in modern Japanese fiction. The score stops short of the top tier because the collection is uneven, with Moonlight Shadow treading the same ground less well, because the story is slight by design, and because English readers still meet it through a single translation that shows its age. For the length of an evening, though, few books are better company.

Read the full review →

The Alchemist

The Alchemist: a beloved spiritual fable whose wisdom rarely goes beyond the surface

The Alchemist is warm, readable and sincere, and its enormous popularity reflects a real hunger for hopeful stories about purpose. Yet its reliance on archetypes, repetitive aphorisms and a simplistic worldview limit its literary value. It lands in mixed territory: a pleasant parable for some, an overrated one for others, and rarely more than the sum of its maxims.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.